Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
South Florida Theft Attorney
Miami Federal Criminal Defense Attorney / South Florida Theft Attorney

South Florida Theft Attorney

Anyone in South Florida who has been accused of taking something that does not belong to them faces a decision that is easy to underestimate: whether to treat the accusation as a minor problem that will pass, or as a case that deserves a defense from day one. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. handles theft and related property charges across Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe Counties, and it is the firm people turn to when a South Florida theft attorney is needed in state court or when the same conduct is being investigated by federal agents.

Florida does not treat theft as one offense with one punishment. The label on the charge, and everything that follows from it, depends on what the State says the property was worth, where it was taken from, and how it is described in the charging document. A shoplifting arrest where the value sits just under a threshold is a misdemeanor. A value just over it is a felony that can follow a person through every background check for the rest of their life. Because so much turns on a number, the first conversations a person has about the case often matter more than the later ones.

How Florida Grades Theft and Why the Dollar Figure Drives Everything

Under Section 812.014, the seriousness of a theft charge is set largely by value. Property worth $100 or more but less than $750 is petit theft of the first degree, a first-degree misdemeanor, unless it was taken from a dwelling, in which case the same value is treated as third-degree grand theft. Once value reaches $750 and stays under $20,000, the offense is third-degree grand theft, a third-degree felony. From $20,000 up to but not including $100,000 it becomes second-degree grand theft, a second-degree felony. At $100,000 or more it is first-degree grand theft, a first-degree felony.

Those classes carry real exposure. A third-degree felony is punishable by up to 5 years and a fine of up to $5,000. A second-degree felony carries up to 15 years and a fine of up to $10,000. A first-degree felony can carry up to 30 years, or life when a statute specifically provides for it, with a fine of up to $10,000. A first-degree misdemeanor tops out at a year in county jail and a $1,000 fine. These are maximums set by law, not predictions of what a judge will impose, but they explain why a disagreement over whether an item was worth $700 or $800 can be the most important dispute in the case.

Valuation is also where cases are most open to challenge. The State generally has to prove what the property was worth, and fair market value is not the same thing as a sticker price, a replacement cost, or a figure supplied by an interested complainant. Used goods, items with no resale market, and property aggregated across several alleged takings all raise questions. Where the State combines multiple incidents into a single count to cross a felony line, the aggregation itself can be scrutinized.

Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for a Theft Charge

The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is led by attorney Nayib Hassan, a former Broward County Assistant State Attorney who has spent more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system. As a prosecutor he handled thousands of cases and tried hundreds to verdict, which means he has sat on the other side of the table deciding which theft cases are strong, which are thin, and what a prosecutor needs before a charge can be sustained. The firm serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe Counties, along with Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens, and it defends Florida state charges as well as federal cases in the Southern District of Florida.

Mr. Hassan is fluent in Spanish and speaks directly with clients and their families without an interpreter, a real advantage in a region where many families are more comfortable discussing a case in their own language. He is recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and teaches as an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University. He has also presented continuing legal education programs on federal court practice to other defense attorneys, and his cases have drawn coverage from outlets including The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald.

The firm intentionally limits its caseload so that every client receives direct, personal attention from the attorney handling the case, and it is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. In multi-defendant matters Mr. Hassan has obtained dismissals and, in another case, one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. That record matters for theft clients because many theft cases involve more than one accused person, and the person who makes the right decisions early often ends up in a very different position from the others.

Theft Charges We Defend Across South Florida

  • Retail Theft and Shoplifting: Store detentions at malls and big-box retailers in Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach usually begin as petit theft under Section 812.014, but the charge can climb to a felony when the merchandise value reaches $750 or when the State alleges a pattern of takings.
  • Grand Theft in Three Degrees: Third-degree grand theft covers $750 up to $20,000, second-degree covers $20,000 up to $100,000, and first-degree covers $100,000 or more, so valuation evidence becomes the center of the defense.
  • Theft From a Dwelling: Property worth $100 or more but under $750 is ordinarily a misdemeanor, yet the same property taken from a dwelling is charged as third-degree grand theft, a felony.
  • Employee and Embezzlement-Style Theft: Accusations by an employer that a bookkeeper, manager, or cashier diverted funds often turn on records, authorization, and intent rather than on any dispute that money moved.
  • Theft Tied to Federal Programs and Financial Institutions: Conduct that touches Medicare, SBA or PPP funds, banks, or interstate wires can be charged federally as fraud or related offenses, with sentencing driven by the alleged loss amount.
  • Theft Combined With Money Laundering or Smuggling: Stolen proceeds that moved through accounts, real estate, or across borders can generate laundering and cash-reporting counts, and with them the risk of forfeiture.
  • Identity Theft and Credit Card Fraud: Use of another person’s card or personal information is often charged alongside or in place of ordinary theft, with its own elements and its own evidence of intent.
  • Vehicle and Property Theft Disputes: Allegations involving borrowed cars, equipment on loan, or items taken in the course of a business or relationship dispute frequently hinge on whether the accused believed they had a right to the property.

What to Do in the First Days After a Theft Accusation

The most useful thing a person can do after being arrested, cited, or contacted by investigators is to stop explaining. Statements to a store loss-prevention officer, a police detective, or a federal agent are routinely the strongest evidence in a theft case, because intent is the element the State has the hardest time proving otherwise. A casual comment that something “was going to be returned” or “was just borrowed” can be repackaged as an admission. Be polite, give identifying information, decline to discuss the facts, and call a defense lawyer before any interview.

If you are arrested in Miami-Dade, a misdemeanor case begins at jail arraignment held on weekdays in the morning and early afternoon at the Richard E. Gerstein Justice Building, while felony cases are heard by the Circuit Criminal Division of the Eleventh Judicial Circuit at that same courthouse. Weekend and holiday felony bond hearings take place once a day, right after the morning misdemeanor arraignments. In Broward the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit handles the case from Fort Lauderdale, in Palm Beach the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit sits in West Palm Beach with additional courthouses serving the north, south, and western parts of the county, and in Monroe County the Sixteenth Judicial Circuit operates from Key West, Marathon, and Tavernier. Knowing which court will hear the case, and who the likely decision-makers are, shapes how a defense is built.

Gather and preserve anything that bears on value or ownership: receipts, texts, emails, bank records, invoices, lease or loan paperwork, and anything showing you had permission to possess or use the property. Do not delete messages, and do not contact the accuser to smooth things over, since that contact can be framed as pressure or an admission. If the accuser offers to drop the matter in exchange for payment, understand that restitution does not end a criminal case, because the decision to prosecute belongs to the State Attorney’s Office and not to the complainant.

Timing also matters for old allegations. A prosecution for a first-degree felony must generally begin within 4 years of the offense, other felonies within 3 years, and a first-degree misdemeanor within 2 years, with certain categories, such as some insurance and workers’ compensation fraud felonies, carrying a 5-year window. When the State waits too long to file, the deadline itself can be a complete defense, and a lawyer should check it at the outset rather than assume the case is timely.

Defenses, Reductions, and Protecting Your Record

Theft is a specific-intent offense, so the defense often begins with what the accused actually knew and meant. Claims of right, a good-faith belief that the property was yours or that you were entitled to it, mistaken ownership, consent from the owner, and genuine business or family disputes over who owns what are all recognized lines of defense. In shoplifting cases, the questions include whether the detention and any search were lawful, whether surveillance footage actually shows concealment and leaving without paying, and whether the person who made the accusation will appear to testify.

Negotiation is frequently where the best result is found. Because the dollar value controls the classification, evidence that the property was worth less than the State claims can move a felony into misdemeanor territory. Prosecutors may also consider diversion, restitution arrangements, or reduced charges depending on a person’s history and the strength of the proof. Mr. Hassan’s years as a prosecutor inform how he approaches those conversations, including when to push for dismissal and when a negotiated outcome is the smarter course.

The long-term record deserves as much attention as the sentence. A person adjudicated guilty of a felony cannot have that record sealed or expunged in Florida, which is why avoiding an adjudication of guilt can matter more than anything else about the outcome. Sealing and expunction are also never automatic. A person must first apply to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement for a certificate of eligibility, the court may not act until the certificate is issued, a certificate for sealing is valid for 12 months, and even an eligible applicant has no right to relief because the judge may deny the request. Eligibility is also limited to one arrest or incident in most circumstances, and an applicant who has previously had a Florida record sealed or expunged generally cannot do it again. Where no charging document was ever filed, expunction may be available, which is one reason to engage a lawyer before formal charges are decided.

Questions About South Florida Theft Charges

What is the difference between petit theft and grand theft in Florida?

The difference is mainly value and circumstances. Property worth $100 or more but less than $750 is petit theft, a first-degree misdemeanor, unless it was taken from a dwelling. Property worth $750 or more is grand theft, a felony, with the degree rising as the value reaches $20,000 and $100,000.

Can a shoplifting charge be a felony?

Yes. If the value of the merchandise reaches $750, the charge is third-degree grand theft rather than a misdemeanor. The State may also try to combine several alleged incidents to cross that line, which is a point worth challenging.

How much jail time can I face for theft?

It depends on the class. A first-degree misdemeanor carries up to one year, a third-degree felony up to 5 years, a second-degree felony up to 15 years, and a first-degree felony up to 30 years or life where a statute specifically provides for it. Those are statutory maximums, and actual outcomes depend on the facts, the person’s history, and the strength of the evidence.

What if I paid the store or returned the property?

Paying or returning an item does not automatically end a criminal case. The State Attorney’s Office decides whether to prosecute, and restitution is one factor among several. It can help in negotiations, but it should not be offered without advice, because it may be treated as an admission.

Is a first-time theft arrest treated differently?

A clean record helps in negotiations and at sentencing, and it can open the door to alternatives to conviction in some cases. It does not change how the offense is classified, which is still driven by value and circumstances.

How long can prosecutors wait before charging a theft?

A first-degree felony must generally be commenced within 4 years, other felonies within 3 years, and a first-degree misdemeanor within 2 years. Some specific categories have longer periods, and the clock can depend on when the offense occurred, so the dates should be reviewed carefully.

Can a theft charge become a federal case?

It can. When the property involved federal funds, a bank, Medicare, SBA or PPP money, or wires across state lines, federal agents and prosecutors in the Southern District of Florida may become involved. Federal sentencing relies heavily on the alleged loss amount, and forfeiture of assets is possible.

Will a theft conviction affect my job or professional license?

Theft is generally treated as a crime involving dishonesty, which can matter to employers, licensing boards, and background screeners. The effect depends on the profession and the outcome of the case, which is why avoiding a conviction or an adjudication of guilt is often a central goal.

Can I get a theft arrest sealed or expunged?

Possibly, but not if you were adjudicated guilty of a felony. You must first obtain a certificate of eligibility from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, and the court retains discretion to deny the request. Where charges were never filed or were dismissed, expunction may be possible, subject to the one-arrest limit.

What if I was accused by a former employer or business partner?

These cases often grow out of civil or financial disputes where the real question is authorization or ownership. Records, emails, and prior dealings between the parties become central evidence, and a person should avoid communicating with the accuser about the allegation.

Do I need a lawyer for a misdemeanor shoplifting charge?

A lawyer is worth considering even for a misdemeanor, because a conviction can create a record that affects employment, housing, and later cases. A defense attorney can look for weaknesses in the detention and the proof, negotiate the outcome, and advise on record-clearing options.

How soon should I call after being contacted by investigators?

Before you answer any questions. The firm is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and early involvement can affect whether charges are filed, how they are worded, and whether a voluntary surrender can be arranged rather than an arrest.

Serving Theft Defense Clients Across South Florida

The firm’s South Florida theft defense work begins in Miami-Dade County and reaches clients in Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens, along with neighboring communities that feed into the Eleventh Judicial Circuit. It extends north into Broward County, where cases move through the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit in Fort Lauderdale, and into Palm Beach County, where the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit sits in West Palm Beach and additional courthouses serve the north, south, and western parts of the county. It also reaches Monroe County and the Keys, where the Sixteenth Judicial Circuit operates from Key West, Marathon, and Tavernier.

Because theft allegations can cross into federal territory, the firm also appears in the Southern District of Florida, whose courthouses sit in Miami, Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, Key West, and Fort Pierce, and it represents clients in federal courts across the country and in matters involving Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba. Whether a case starts as a store detention in a Kendall shopping center or an employer complaint in downtown Miami, the same attorney follows it from the first call through resolution.

Speak With a South Florida Theft Defense Attorney Today

The decisions made right after a theft accusation, what to say, what to preserve, and whether to engage with investigators, often shape the rest of the case. A South Florida theft defense attorney at the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. can review the charge, test the State’s valuation and proof, and explain your realistic options in plain terms. Call to arrange a confidential consultation at any hour, and let the firm start building your defense before the case is decided for you.

Book Your Consultation
* Required Field

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A., through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms