South Florida Insurance Fraud Attorney
Insurance fraud cases in South Florida rarely begin with a knock on the door. They begin with a claim file, a flagged billing pattern, or a recorded statement given to an adjuster who seemed friendly. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. defends individuals, business owners, and medical professionals accused of fraud-related offenses in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe Counties, and in the federal courts of the Southern District of Florida. Anyone looking for a South Florida insurance fraud attorney should know that these cases are often built on paperwork long before anyone is charged.
Which prosecutors take the case depends on the insurance involved. A false auto, homeowner’s, or life insurance claim is usually handled as a Florida state felony. A scheme involving Medicare, Medicaid, or a billing operation that crosses state lines can end up in federal court. The charge, the court, and the potential sentence all turn on that distinction, and it is the first thing worth sorting out.
The other early question is timing. Insurers have their own fraud units, and they refer files to law enforcement. Statements made during a routine claim investigation can end up as evidence. What you say and sign before you speak to a lawyer often shapes the case more than anything that happens later.
What Counts as Insurance Fraud in Florida and Federal Court
Florida’s insurance fraud statute is codified at section 817.234, and it reaches more conduct than most people expect. It covers knowingly presenting a false or misleading statement in support of a claim, submitting a claim for a loss that never happened, inflating a legitimate loss, and helping someone else do any of these things. Under Florida’s general limitations statute, a felony violation of section 817.234 must be charged within 5 years of the violation, which is longer than the 3-year window for most other third- and second-degree felonies.
Penalties follow the value of the claim and the theft classification. Grand theft in the third degree covers property valued at $750 or more but under $20,000, and it is a third-degree felony carrying up to 5 years. Between $20,000 and $100,000 it becomes a second-degree felony with up to 15 years. At $100,000 or more it is a first-degree felony punishable by up to 30 years. Fines scale too, up to $5,000, $10,000, and $10,000 for those three tiers respectively.
The law also draws a distinction that matters in practice: a mistake is not a crime. An honest error in a repair estimate, a disagreement over the value of a loss, or a billing code entered wrongly by office staff is a civil or administrative dispute. Prosecutors must show intent to deceive, and much of the defense work happens in that gap.
Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for Insurance Fraud Defense
The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is a criminal defense firm led by attorney and founder Nayib Hassan, serving clients throughout Miami-Dade County, Broward County, Palm Beach County, Monroe County, and South Florida as a whole. The firm represents business owners, executives, health care professionals, and individuals facing investigation or charges, and it limits its caseload on purpose so that the attorney handling the case is the one who answers the phone, reviews the records, and appears in court.
Mr. Hassan spent time as a Broward County Assistant State Attorney, handling thousands of cases and trying hundreds to verdict, and he has more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system. That prosecutor’s background matters in fraud work, because these cases are decided by how charging decisions get made and how evidence is weighed for trial. He is admitted to the federal courts for the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida, the District of Columbia, and the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, and he has defended clients in federal courts in Florida, the Southern District of New York, Texas, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, South Carolina, and California.
He is fluent in Spanish, which matters for the many South Florida families who prefer to discuss a case without an interpreter. He is recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and teaches as an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University. His cases have been covered by The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald. He has also represented defendants in multi-defendant cases where charges were dismissed and where a client received one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. The firm is available around the clock, and consultations are confidential.
Common Insurance Fraud Allegations in South Florida
- Staged or Exaggerated Auto Accident Claims: Allegations that a collision was arranged, that passengers were added who were not in the car, or that injuries were overstated. These cases often rest on treatment records from clinics and on the statements of other participants.
- Property and Hurricane Damage Claims: Storm seasons produce large volumes of homeowner and commercial claims, and insurers scrutinize inflated repair scopes, pre-existing damage, and contractor invoices. Charges depend on proof that the claimant knew the figures were false.
- Medicare and Medicaid Billing Fraud: Physicians, clinic operators, pharmacy owners, home health agencies, laboratories, and equipment suppliers can face federal charges over billing for services not rendered, medically unnecessary treatment, or kickbacks for referrals. Miami-Dade has long been a center of healthcare fraud enforcement.
- Private Health and Disability Insurance Fraud: Claims involving falsified diagnoses, misrepresented work capacity, or services billed to private carriers. These can be prosecuted under Florida law or, when wires and mail are involved, as federal wire or mail fraud.
- Life Insurance Misrepresentation: Allegations that an applicant concealed a health condition, that a policy was taken out on someone without consent, or that a death claim was supported by false documents.
- Workers’ Compensation Fraud: A felony violation of section 440.105 shares the 5-year charging window with insurance fraud. Accusations include working while collecting benefits, misstating wages or payroll to lower premiums, and fabricating injuries.
- Provider and Billing Staff Exposure: Office managers, billers, and coders can be named alongside owners, sometimes on the theory that they must have known. Their role in the paperwork often looks different from the owner’s.
What to Do If You Are Under Investigation for Insurance Fraud
Stop talking about the claim to anyone connected with it. That includes adjusters, special investigators, agents who call to “clear up a few questions,” and former employees or business partners. Recorded statements and signed affidavits are routinely used later. Politely decline, say you will respond through counsel, and then call a lawyer before anything else is said or signed.
Preserve everything. Do not delete texts, emails, invoices, patient or client files, bank records, or photographs, and do not alter or reorganize documents. Destroying records after an inquiry begins can lead to an obstruction charge that is harder to defend than the underlying claim. Gather what you already have, such as the policy, the claim submission, repair estimates, treatment records, and correspondence, so your lawyer can review it with you.
If you receive a subpoena, a target letter, or a search warrant, treat it as urgent. Early contact with prosecutors can sometimes shape whether charges are filed and how they are framed, and it may allow arrangements such as a voluntary surrender rather than an arrest. In Miami-Dade, state felony cases are heard in the Circuit Criminal Division of the Eleventh Judicial Circuit, at the Richard E. Gerstein Justice Building in Miami. Federal cases arising from the area are heard in the Southern District of Florida, which sits in Miami, Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, Key West, and Fort Pierce. Broward state cases go to the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit in Fort Lauderdale, Palm Beach cases to the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit in West Palm Beach, and Monroe County cases to the Sixteenth Judicial Circuit, which sits in Key West, Marathon, and Tavernier.
Common mistakes are predictable. People try to explain themselves to an investigator, assume a small claim cannot lead to a felony, move money or assets in a way that looks like concealment, or contact co-participants to “get stories straight.” Each of these can create new problems. An experienced criminal defense attorney can handle contact with investigators and prosecutors so that nothing you say becomes an unforced error.
How These Cases Are Built and Where They Can Be Challenged
Insurance fraud prosecutions are paper cases. Investigators assemble claim files, recorded statements, bank records, medical charts, billing data, and communications, and then argue that the pattern shows knowledge. That makes each document a potential point of attack. Defense work focuses on whether the statement was actually false, whether it was material to the claim, whether the defendant made it or merely signed what someone else prepared, and whether the evidence shows intent rather than carelessness.
Where an accountant, broker, public adjuster, contractor, or billing company prepared the submission, the question becomes who knew what. Reliance on a professional is not an automatic defense, but it bears directly on intent. In larger schemes, defendants are often pressured to cooperate against others, and the quality of the government’s cooperating witnesses becomes central. Credibility, payment arrangements, and prior statements all matter.
Sentencing is the other major battleground. In federal court, the alleged loss amount can drive the recommended range, so challenging how that number is calculated can change the outcome as much as challenging guilt. Forfeiture is also a concern. Money, property, and business assets connected to alleged proceeds can be seized, sometimes before trial. Where charges are federal, the firm also handles appeals and post-conviction relief in the Eleventh Circuit.
Insurance Fraud Defense Questions Answered
Is insurance fraud a felony in Florida?
It can be. Section 817.234 makes knowingly submitting false or misleading information in support of a claim a crime, and the felony grade tracks the value involved, much like the theft classifications. The more money at issue, the higher the degree and the longer the potential sentence.
How long can prosecutors wait to charge insurance fraud in Florida?
A felony violation of section 817.234 must generally be commenced within 5 years of the violation. That is longer than the 4 years for most first-degree felonies and the 3 years for other felonies. Federal charges follow federal limitation periods, which can differ.
What is the difference between state and federal insurance fraud charges?
State charges usually involve a private insurer and a Florida claim. Federal charges arise when government programs such as Medicare or Medicaid are involved, or when mail, wire communications, or interstate activity are part of the alleged scheme. Federal cases tend to involve longer investigations and sentencing driven by the Sentencing Guidelines.
Can I be charged if I did not personally file the claim?
Yes. Florida law reaches people who assist, conspire, or knowingly participate in preparing or presenting a false claim. That is why billing staff, contractors, brokers, and family members sometimes find themselves named. Prosecutors still have to show knowledge and intent.
What if I made an honest mistake on my claim?
An honest error is not fraud. The government must prove you knowingly made a false statement or acted with intent to deceive. Inflated estimates, misunderstood policy terms, and clerical coding mistakes are often disputes over value or procedure, not crimes. Documents showing how the numbers were derived can be important.
Should I talk to the insurance company’s investigator?
Not before speaking with a lawyer. Statements given in a claim investigation can be shared with law enforcement and used later. A lawyer can decide whether, how, and in what form to respond so you keep cooperating with the claim without handing over evidence.
Can I lose my professional license over an insurance fraud charge?
Possibly. Physicians, pharmacists, contractors, and other licensed professionals can face disciplinary action separate from the criminal case, and a conviction or even an investigation can trigger review. The criminal defense strategy should account for that from the start.
Can I be arrested before any charges are filed?
Arrest generally follows an arrest warrant or probable cause. In many cases, though, lawyers can contact prosecutors in advance and arrange a voluntary surrender, which avoids a surprise arrest and can help with bond. That option is far easier to arrange before an indictment or warrant than after.
Will the government try to take my assets?
It can. Federal and state law allow forfeiture of property tied to alleged fraud proceeds, and seizures can happen before a verdict. Defense work includes arguing that assets are untainted and challenging the government’s tracing of funds.
How long does an insurance fraud case take in South Florida?
Timelines vary widely. A state case involving a single claim may resolve within months, while a federal healthcare or multi-defendant case can run more than a year because of the volume of discovery. Early investigation-stage involvement can change both the pace and the outcome.
Is it worth hiring a lawyer for a smaller claim?
Yes, because the felony grade follows value, but even lower-dollar cases carry criminal records, restitution, and possible collateral consequences. A lawyer can address the case before it escalates and can negotiate on both charges and restitution.
Serving Insurance Fraud Clients Across South Florida
The firm represents clients throughout Miami-Dade County, including Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens. It also handles cases in Broward County, Palm Beach County, and Monroe County, where state matters are heard in Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, and the Keys. Because insurance fraud investigations are often federal, the firm appears in the Southern District of Florida’s courthouses and takes cases in federal courts nationwide, including matters with connections to Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba.
Whether the case began with a claim in Hialeah, a clinic billing review in Doral, a storm loss in the Keys, or a federal inquiry reaching across counties, the work starts the same way: reading the file, understanding what the government can actually prove, and planning how to respond.
Speak With a South Florida Insurance Fraud Defense Attorney
If an insurer has questioned your claim, an investigator has asked to interview you, or you have received a subpoena or target letter, the first conversation with a South Florida insurance fraud defense attorney is often the most valuable one. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and consultations are confidential. Call to talk through where you stand and what can still be done before charges are filed.
