Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Miami Insurance Fraud Attorney
Miami Federal Criminal Defense Attorney / Miami Insurance Fraud Attorney

Miami Insurance Fraud Attorney

The best outcome in an insurance fraud investigation is the one that never reaches a courtroom: no charge filed, no arrest, no record. The second best is a charge reduced or dismissed because the proof of intent was never there. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is a criminal defense firm that handles state and federal fraud cases, and as a Miami insurance fraud attorney it represents clients in Miami, Miami-Dade County, and across South Florida who are under investigation or have been charged.

Insurance fraud in Miami covers a wide range of conduct: a staged or exaggerated auto claim, a padded property loss after a storm, a questionable workers’ compensation claim, or Medicare and Medicaid billing patterns that investigators read as fraud rather than error. The conduct, the amount, and the insurer or program involved decide whether the case lands in the Eleventh Judicial Circuit or in the Southern District of Florida.

Most of these cases begin quietly. An insurer’s special investigations unit flags a claim, a recorded statement is requested, and a referral goes to prosecutors. By the time someone is contacted, much of the paper trail has already been assembled.

How Insurance Fraud Cases Are Charged in Miami

Insurance fraud is not a single offense, and the forum matters. State prosecutors in Miami-Dade bring most claims-related cases under Florida’s fraud statutes, often alongside grand theft, which is graded by the value taken. Property valued at $750 or more but under $20,000 is a third-degree felony. At $20,000 or more but under $100,000 it is a second-degree felony. At $100,000 or more it is a first-degree felony.

Those grades translate directly into exposure. A third-degree felony carries up to 5 years, a second-degree felony up to 15 years, and a first-degree felony up to 30 years, with fines of up to $5,000, $10,000, and $10,000 respectively. A first-degree felony can carry life only when a statute specifically provides for it.

Federal charges follow when the victim is a federal program, the claim crosses state lines, or the scheme used wires, mail, or a bank. Medicare and Medicaid billing cases are the clearest example. Prosecutors in the Southern District of Florida, whose Miami courthouses include the Wilkie D. Ferguson, Jr. United States Courthouse, regularly pair fraud counts with conspiracy and money laundering counts. That can turn a billing dispute into a case with forfeiture exposure.

Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan for an Insurance Fraud Defense

Nayib Hassan, Attorney and Founder, spent years as a Broward County Assistant State Attorney before moving to defense work. He has more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system, handled thousands of cases as a prosecutor, and tried hundreds to verdict. That background matters in fraud cases because they are won or lost on how a prosecutor weighs intent, documents, and trial risk.

The firm represents business owners, professionals, executives, and individuals in state and federal court throughout Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe Counties, and in federal courts across the country. Mr. Hassan is admitted to the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida, the federal court for the District of Columbia, and the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals. He is fluent in Spanish and speaks with clients and families directly, without an interpreter.

He is recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, and serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. He teaches as an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University and has presented continuing legal education programs on federal court practice to other defense attorneys. His cases have drawn coverage from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald.

On results, Mr. Hassan has represented defendants in multi-defendant cases where charges were dismissed and where a client received one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. The firm limits its caseload on purpose so the attorney handling your case is the one who answers your call, and it is available around the clock. A confidential consultation is available.

Common Insurance Fraud Allegations in South Florida

  • Auto Insurance Claims: Allegations of staged collisions, inflated injury claims, or misrepresented vehicle damage. Prosecutors often rely on medical billing, repair invoices, and recorded statements given to the insurer before anyone consulted a lawyer.
  • Property and Storm Damage Claims: Hurricane and water-loss claims invite scrutiny when a contractor’s estimate, an adjuster’s report, and the policyholder’s account do not match. Charges can follow from a disputed scope of damage rather than any intent to deceive.
  • Health Insurance and Medicare Billing: Clinics, pharmacies, laboratories, home health agencies, and equipment suppliers face federal exposure when billing patterns or referral arrangements are read as fraud. Many of these cases involve wire fraud and conspiracy counts.
  • Workers’ Compensation Fraud: Claims for benefits while working, misstated injuries, or employers who understate payroll to cut premiums. Florida’s specific limitations period for these offenses is longer than for most felonies.
  • Grand Theft Tied to a Claim: The dollar value of what was allegedly obtained sets the felony degree under Florida’s theft statute, so the valuation fight is often central to the defense.
  • Federal Wire and Mail Fraud: Claims submitted by email, online portal, or mail can support federal counts, which are investigated by agencies such as the FBI and the HHS Office of Inspector General.
  • Conspiracy and Money Laundering Add-Ons: When several people are involved or money moves between accounts, prosecutors add conspiracy and laundering counts that raise exposure and open the door to forfeiture of funds and property.

What to Do If You Are Under Investigation for Insurance Fraud

Stop talking about the claim. That includes the insurer’s investigator, a field adjuster, and anyone who says they just need a quick recorded statement. Statements to insurers and to agents are routinely used as evidence, and an inaccurate answer can become its own charge.

Call a lawyer before you respond to a subpoena, a target letter, or a request for an interview. Early contact often leaves room to present information to prosecutors, narrow what is charged, and arrange a voluntary surrender instead of an arrest. Those options narrow quickly once charges are filed.

Preserve everything. Do not delete emails, texts, photographs, invoices, or billing records, and do not ask others to. Destroying material after an inquiry begins can create an obstruction problem far worse than the claim itself. Gather the claim file, policy documents, repair or medical records, and any correspondence with the insurer, and give them to your lawyer rather than explaining them to anyone else.

Know where the case is likely to go. State felony cases in Miami-Dade are heard by the Eleventh Judicial Circuit’s Circuit Criminal Division at the Richard E. Gerstein Justice Building. Misdemeanor cases are handled in county criminal court. Federal cases in Miami are filed in the Southern District of Florida, and cases arising in Broward, Palm Beach, or Monroe County may be heard in Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, or Key West.

Timing also matters on the government’s side. Prosecutors have a limited window to file. A first-degree felony must generally be commenced within 4 years and most other felonies within 3 years, but a felony violation of the workers’ compensation fraud or insurance fraud statutes can be charged within 5 years of the violation. Do not assume an older claim is safe without having a lawyer check the dates.

How These Cases Unfold and Where Defenses Come From

The typical case moves from claim review, to referral, to a subpoena or interview request, to charges. Each stage is a chance to change the direction of the case. A defense lawyer who is retained at the claim stage can sometimes resolve the matter administratively or persuade prosecutors that the facts show a dispute, not a crime.

Intent is the center of most defenses. Prosecutors must show a knowing misrepresentation, not a mistake, a misunderstanding of policy language, or reliance on a contractor, broker, or billing company. Documents that look damaging in isolation often read differently with context, and the firm works through them line by line.

The next pressure point is value. Because felony grade turns on the amount, a challenge to the government’s loss or valuation can move a charge down a degree, or in a federal case move the guideline range. Evidence issues come next: how the insurer’s records were gathered, whether statements were properly obtained, and whether a search or seizure of devices and accounts holds up.

If the case resolves short of trial, the terms still matter. Charges, restitution, and any forfeiture are all negotiable points, and a record that includes a felony adjudication cannot later be sealed or expunged in Florida. That is a reason to treat the first resolution offer with caution.

Insurance Fraud Questions Answered

Is insurance fraud a felony in Florida?

It can be. Many insurance fraud charges are felonies, and related theft charges are graded by the value of what was allegedly taken. Third-degree grand theft starts at $750, second-degree at $20,000, and first-degree at $100,000.

How long can prosecutors wait to charge insurance fraud?

Under Florida law, a felony violation of the insurance fraud statute or the workers’ compensation fraud statute must be commenced within 5 years of the violation. Other felonies carry shorter periods, generally 3 or 4 years, so the charge and the dates both matter.

Should I speak with the insurance company’s investigator?

Not before talking to a lawyer. Statements to insurers can be shared with prosecutors, and an inaccurate or incomplete answer can create exposure of its own.

What is a target letter?

It is a notice from the United States Attorney’s Office that a grand jury is looking at you and that prosecutors believe there is evidence linking you to a crime. It is a strong signal to hire counsel immediately, while there may still be room to influence charging decisions.

Can an honest mistake on a claim be charged as fraud?

Prosecutors still must show intent to deceive. Misread policy terms, clerical errors, and reliance on an adjuster, contractor, or billing company are real defenses, though they have to be documented and presented well.

What is the difference between state and federal insurance fraud charges?

State cases are brought by the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office in the Eleventh Judicial Circuit. Federal cases are brought by the United States Attorney’s Office when federal programs, wires, mail, banks, or interstate activity are involved, and they often carry heavier sentencing consequences.

Can I lose property or bank accounts even before a conviction?

In some cases, yes. Federal fraud and money laundering charges can come with forfeiture of funds and assets, and accounts can be frozen during an investigation. Early legal involvement can help protect assets unconnected to the alleged conduct.

Can a fraud conviction be sealed or expunged later?

Not if you were adjudicated guilty of a felony. A person must also obtain a certificate of eligibility from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement before a court can order a record sealed or expunged, and even then the court has discretion to deny the request.

Do doctors and clinic owners face different risks than individual policyholders?

Yes. Providers and business owners often face federal charges tied to Medicare, Medicaid, or private insurer billing, and may also face licensing and program exclusion consequences. The defense usually turns on separating billing disputes from intentional conduct.

How long does an insurance fraud case take in Miami?

It varies widely. Pre-charge investigations can last months or years, and a charged case may take many months to resolve, longer if it goes to trial or involves several defendants and voluminous financial records.

Should I hire a lawyer if I have not been charged yet?

Yes. This is the stage where a lawyer can have the most influence, including communicating with investigators, presenting information to prosecutors, and negotiating the scope of any charges or a voluntary surrender.

Serving Insurance Fraud Defense Clients Across Miami-Dade and South Florida

From downtown Miami and Brickell through Little Havana, Wynwood, and Coconut Grove, the firm represents clients accused of insurance fraud throughout Miami-Dade County. That includes Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens, along with Miami Lakes, Pinecrest, Cutler Bay, and Sweetwater.

The firm also represents clients in neighboring Broward County, Palm Beach County, and Monroe County, as well as in federal courts across the Southern District of Florida and around the country. Matters with connections to Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba are part of the firm’s regular work, and the firm continues to handle serious state charges throughout Florida.

Speak With a Miami Insurance Fraud Defense Attorney Today

If an insurer, a state investigator, or a federal agent has contacted you about a claim, the choices you make now can shape the entire case. A call to a Miami insurance fraud defense attorney before you answer questions or hand over documents can preserve options that disappear after charges are filed. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Call to schedule a confidential consultation and start building your defense.

Book Your Consultation
* Required Field

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A., through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms