Broward County Medicare Fraud Attorney
Most Medicare fraud investigations that end up in a Broward County courtroom were assembled quietly long before anyone received a subpoena. Claims data gets mined for billing patterns, former employees are interviewed, and patients are contacted by investigators asking whether they actually received the services billed in their name. By the time a clinic owner, physician, or billing manager learns about it, an agent may be standing at the door or a target letter may already be in the mail. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. handles healthcare fraud and other federal criminal cases for clients in Broward County, Miami-Dade County, Palm Beach County, and across South Florida, and the firm works as a Broward County Medicare fraud attorney from the earliest stage of an inquiry through trial and sentencing.
Medicare fraud cases in the Southern District of Florida are rarely about a single bad claim. The government typically builds its theory around a pattern: services billed but not rendered, treatments billed as more expensive than what was provided, medically unnecessary testing, or payments made to steer patients and referrals. Much of the fight in these cases is over intent. A coding mistake, a disagreement about medical necessity, or a poorly documented chart can look very different from a deliberate scheme once the records are examined line by line, and the difference between the two is often the difference between an administrative repayment demand and a federal indictment.
Broward’s mix of medical practices, pharmacies, home health agencies, diagnostic labs, and equipment suppliers means a wide range of people can become subjects of an inquiry, including owners who never touched a claim and employees who simply followed instructions. Understanding who the government believes made the decisions, and who merely carried them out, shapes everything that follows.
Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for a Medicare Fraud Defense
The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is a federal criminal defense firm led by attorney and founder Nayib Hassan, who represents physicians, business owners, executives, and other professionals facing investigation or indictment in Broward County, Miami-Dade County, Palm Beach County, Monroe County, and throughout the Southern District of Florida. The firm limits its caseload on purpose so that every client works directly with the attorney handling the case, and it is reachable around the clock, which matters when agents show up unannounced or an account is frozen on a Friday evening. Consultations are confidential, and Mr. Hassan speaks Spanish fluently, so clients and family members can discuss the case without an interpreter.
Mr. Hassan spent more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system, starting as a Broward County Assistant State Attorney, where he handled thousands of cases and tried hundreds to verdict. That background gives him a working sense of how prosecutors weigh evidence, evaluate trial risk, and decide what to charge. He is admitted to the federal courts in the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida, the federal court for the District of Columbia, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, which hears appeals from Florida federal courts. He has defended clients in federal courts in Florida, the Southern District of New York, Texas, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, South Carolina, and California, and his cases have drawn coverage from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald.
Recognition from the profession includes selection among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers and a 10.0 Avvo rating. He serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, teaches as an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University, and has presented continuing legal education programs on federal court practice to other defense attorneys. In multi-defendant federal drug conspiracy cases, a close cousin of large healthcare fraud conspiracies, he has obtained dismissals for clients and, in another matter, one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. For a healthcare provider whose license, income, and freedom are all on the line, that combination of prosecutorial insight and federal trial experience is what a defense is built on.
Common Medicare Fraud Allegations Brought Against Broward Providers
- Billing for Services Not Rendered: The most straightforward theory of healthcare fraud, usually proven through patient interviews, appointment records, and comparison of claims against clinic schedules. Charges commonly include healthcare fraud and wire fraud under federal law.
- Upcoding and Unbundling: Billing a higher-paying code than the service delivered, or splitting one procedure into several claims. Defenses often turn on whether the coding reflected a genuine, documented interpretation of ambiguous billing rules rather than intent to deceive.
- Medically Unnecessary Treatment and Testing: Common in laboratories, diagnostic imaging, and physical therapy clinics. The government relies on reviewing physicians to say care was unneeded; the defense frequently challenges those opinions and the standards they apply.
- Kickbacks and Illegal Referral Arrangements: Payments to patient recruiters, marketers, or other providers in exchange for referrals can be prosecuted under the federal anti-kickback statute. Distinguishing a lawful marketing or consulting arrangement from a payment for patients is often the central issue.
- Home Health and Durable Medical Equipment Schemes: Agencies and suppliers are scrutinized for patients who did not qualify, equipment that was never delivered, or physician orders obtained improperly.
- Pharmacy Billing Cases: Allegations include billing for drugs never dispensed or dispensed in different quantities than claimed, with pharmacy owners and pharmacists both exposed.
- Related Money Laundering and Forfeiture: Prosecutors often add money laundering counts when proceeds moved through business accounts or real estate, and seek forfeiture of funds, property, and vehicles tied to the alleged scheme.
- False Statements and Obstruction: Statements made to agents, auditors, or program integrity contractors can become separate charges, sometimes more provable than the underlying billing allegation.
What to Do When Medicare Investigators Come Calling
The first decision most people face is whether to talk. Agents from the HHS Office of Inspector General or the FBI often present an interview as routine, a few questions to clear things up. Anything said can be used later, and an answer the government considers false or incomplete can become its own federal charge regardless of whether the billing was proper. Politely decline to answer substantive questions, take the agent’s name and contact information, and call a lawyer before any further contact. The same applies to a records request from a Medicare contractor or a payment suspension notice: these administrative steps can feed a criminal inquiry, and responses should be reviewed by counsel before they go out.
If a search warrant is executed at an office or home, do not obstruct agents, but do not volunteer explanations either. Ask for a copy of the warrant, note what is taken, and avoid discussing the facts with staff in ways that could later be portrayed as coordinating stories. Do not delete, alter, or discard any chart, billing record, email, or text message; destroying records after learning of an investigation can create obstruction exposure far worse than the original problem. Preserve everything, and let your lawyer handle how records are collected and produced.
Timing is the most valuable asset in these cases. A target letter or grand jury subpoena opens a window in which counsel can sometimes present information to prosecutors, negotiate the scope of any charges, arrange a voluntary surrender rather than an arrest, and protect assets unconnected to the alleged conduct. Once an indictment is returned, much of that flexibility disappears. Federal cases arising in Broward County are heard in the Southern District of Florida, whose Fort Lauderdale courthouse sits in the county seat, while related proceedings may also be brought in Miami or West Palm Beach depending on where the government venues the case. Initial appearances and detention hearings move quickly, so having a lawyer already familiar with the file matters.
How a Federal Healthcare Fraud Case Unfolds
A typical case begins with data. Medicare claims are screened for statistical outliers, such as a provider billing far more of a certain code than peers, and those flags lead to audits, interviews, and sometimes undercover patients or cooperating insiders. Prosecutors then decide whether to pursue the matter civilly, criminally, or both. Many providers face parallel civil and administrative consequences, including payment suspensions and exclusion from federal healthcare programs, which can end a practice even before a criminal case concludes.
If charges are filed, the case moves into discovery, which in a healthcare fraud matter can mean tens of thousands of claims, patient files, bank records, and recorded communications. This is where defense work separates cases. Sampling methods used to extrapolate losses can be challenged, billing records can be reconstructed to show that services were in fact provided, and the government’s proof of knowledge and intent can be tested against what the provider actually understood about confusing program rules. Motions to suppress can attack searches and seizures, and motions to dismiss can attack defective charging.
Sentencing in federal court is driven by the United States Sentencing Guidelines, and in fraud cases the alleged loss amount often moves the recommended range more than any other factor. There is no parole in the federal system, so the sentence imposed is close to the time actually served. That is why the loss calculation, the role in the offense, and any claimed enhancements are contested as vigorously as guilt itself. Appeals from the Southern District go to the Eleventh Circuit, and the firm also handles post-conviction relief.
Medicare Fraud Questions Broward Clients Ask
What is the difference between a billing error and Medicare fraud?
Criminal healthcare fraud requires that the government prove intent to defraud, not merely that a claim was wrong. Honest coding mistakes, good-faith disagreements about medical necessity, and misunderstandings of complicated rules can lead to repayment demands without being crimes. The line is often drawn by documentation, internal communications, and what the provider knew when the claims were submitted.
Should I speak with a Medicare auditor or federal agent without a lawyer?
No. Even a friendly conversation can produce statements later characterized as inconsistent or false. Ask to schedule any interview after you have counsel, and let your lawyer decide whether and how to participate.
What is a target letter, and what should I do if I receive one?
A target letter tells you that the United States Attorney’s Office considers you a subject of a grand jury investigation with evidence tying you to a crime. It is one of the most important moments to retain a lawyer, because there may still be room to influence whether charges are brought and what they are.
Can employees and billing staff be charged, or only owners and doctors?
Anyone who knowingly participates can be charged, including billing personnel, office managers, recruiters, and technicians. Prosecutors frequently pressure lower-level participants to cooperate against owners, so staff members who receive contact from agents should also consult independent counsel.
Can the government freeze my accounts before I am charged?
Yes. Funds and property alleged to be proceeds of fraud can be seized or restrained, and Medicare can suspend payments to a provider during an investigation. Challenging overbroad seizures and protecting assets unrelated to the alleged conduct is an early priority.
What penalties can a Medicare fraud conviction carry?
Federal healthcare fraud and related offenses such as wire fraud, kickback violations, and money laundering carry substantial prison terms, restitution, and forfeiture. Actual exposure depends heavily on the loss amount and guideline enhancements, which is why those calculations are a central focus. A conviction can also lead to exclusion from federal healthcare programs and licensing consequences.
Will a criminal case affect my medical or pharmacy license?
It can. State licensing boards may open their own proceedings based on an investigation, charges, or a conviction, and the timing and outcome of the criminal case often drive what happens next. Coordinating the criminal defense with any licensing response is important.
How long does a federal healthcare fraud case take in the Southern District of Florida?
These cases usually take many months and often longer, since discovery is voluminous and complex. Cases involving multiple defendants or extensive financial records tend to run longest, though early negotiations can sometimes resolve matters sooner.
Is it worth hiring a lawyer if I only received a records request or payment suspension?
Yes. Administrative actions can be the first visible sign of a criminal inquiry, and what you submit in response can be used against you. Counsel can help determine whether the matter is purely administrative and shape responses accordingly.
Can I be charged in federal court even though I live and work in Broward County?
Yes. Broward County is part of the Southern District of Florida, and federal prosecutors there routinely bring healthcare fraud cases against Broward providers. Court for the district is held in Fort Lauderdale as well as Miami and West Palm Beach.
Yes. The firm defends serious state matters as well as federal ones, so it can coordinate strategy if state prosecutors or agencies become involved alongside federal investigators.
Serving Medicare Fraud Defense Clients Across Broward County and South Florida
The firm represents healthcare providers and others accused of Medicare fraud throughout Broward County, from Fort Lauderdale and Hollywood to Pembroke Pines, Miramar, Davie, Plantation, Sunrise, Coral Springs, Pompano Beach, Deerfield Beach, Weston, Tamarac, Lauderhill, and Margate. Clients in neighboring Miami-Dade County, including Hialeah, Doral, Miami, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens, rely on the same representation, as do those in Palm Beach County and Monroe County. Because federal practice is not bound by county lines, Mr. Hassan also defends clients charged in federal courts across the country, including matters with connections to Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba. Whether the case involves a single-provider clinic or a large multi-defendant investigation, the work starts with the same careful look at the records.
Speak With a Broward County Medicare Fraud Defense Attorney
If you have received a target letter, a grand jury subpoena, a payment suspension notice, or a visit from federal agents, the decisions you make now will shape what options remain. A Broward County healthcare fraud lawyer who can step in before charges are filed has the best chance of influencing the outcome. Call the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. to schedule a confidential consultation with a Broward County Medicare fraud attorney who is available around the clock and will speak with you directly about your case.
