Broward County Medicaid Fraud Attorney
A letter from the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit, a subpoena for patient files, or a billing audit that suddenly turns into a criminal inquiry can land on a Broward County provider with almost no warning. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. defends physicians, pharmacy owners, clinic operators, home health agencies, laboratories, and billing staff in Broward County, Miami-Dade County, and across South Florida who are under investigation or charged with a Broward County Medicaid fraud attorney level of case: Medicaid, Medicare, and private-insurer billing allegations in both state and federal court.
Medicaid fraud sits in an unusual place in the criminal system. Because Medicaid is funded jointly by the state and federal governments, the same billing conduct can be reviewed by state investigators and by federal agencies such as the HHS Office of Inspector General, and a case that begins as a state inquiry can be handed to the United States Attorney’s Office in the Southern District of Florida, which sits in Fort Lauderdale for Broward matters. Where a case ends up shapes everything that follows, including how loss is counted, what sentence is possible, and what leverage exists in negotiations. Getting a lawyer involved while the matter is still an audit or an interview request often decides which of those paths the case takes.
Why the Charging Decision Matters So Much in a Broward Medicaid Case
Most Medicaid fraud allegations begin as a dispute about paperwork: documentation that does not match the codes billed, services delivered by a staff member whose credentials are questioned, referrals that look too tidy, or patient records that do not support the volume of claims. The criminal question is never whether a mistake was made. It is whether the provider acted knowingly and intended to deceive the program. Billing errors, ambiguous coding rules, reliance on an outside biller or consultant, and honest disagreements about medical necessity are all common in this field, and they are not the same thing as a scheme to defraud.
That distinction drives the defense. Investigators often build a case by sampling claims and extrapolating across a provider’s entire billing history, which can turn a handful of questionable entries into a headline figure. Challenging how those samples were selected, whether the extrapolation is fair, and whether the underlying records were read correctly can change the picture dramatically. In theft-based state charges, the dollar value matters directly: Florida grades grand theft by value, with a third-degree felony for property worth $750 or more but less than $20,000, a second-degree felony from $20,000 up to $100,000, and a first-degree felony at $100,000 or more. A first-degree felony can carry up to 30 years, a second-degree felony up to 15 years, and a third-degree felony up to 5 years. Because the alleged amount can move a case from one tier to the next, the way the government counts and proves loss is often the most contested issue.
Timing rules also matter. Florida generally gives prosecutors four years to bring a first-degree felony and three years for most other felonies, but a felony violation of the insurance fraud statute, section 817.234, carries a five-year window. Federal charges follow their own limitations periods, and a long-running billing pattern can produce counts reaching well back in time. Knowing which clock applies to which count is part of evaluating exposure early.
Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for Healthcare Fraud Defense
The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is a criminal defense firm led by attorney and founder Nayib Hassan, serving clients in Broward County, Palm Beach County, Miami-Dade County, Monroe County, and throughout the Southern District of Florida. The firm’s focus is serious federal and state criminal defense, including healthcare and Medicare fraud, white collar fraud, money laundering, and asset forfeiture, and its practice reaches federal courts across the country. Mr. Hassan limits the firm’s caseload on purpose so that each client works directly with the attorney handling the case, and the firm is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, which matters when agents arrive at a clinic or a records subpoena is served on a Friday afternoon.
Mr. Hassan spent more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system, beginning as a Broward County Assistant State Attorney, where he handled thousands of cases and tried hundreds to verdict. That prosecutorial background informs how he reads a charging decision, anticipates what an Assistant State Attorney or Assistant United States Attorney will emphasize, and prepares a case for trial rather than assuming it will resolve by plea. He is admitted to the federal courts in the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida, the federal court for the District of Columbia, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. He has been recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, and serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. He is also an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University and has presented continuing legal education programs on federal court practice to other defense attorneys.
In multi-defendant prosecutions, Mr. Hassan has represented clients in cases where charges were dismissed and in cases where his client received one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. His cases have drawn coverage from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald. He is fluent in Spanish and speaks directly with clients and family members, which is significant for the many Broward providers and employees who are more comfortable discussing a case in their own language.
Situations That Lead to Medicaid and Healthcare Fraud Charges
- Billing for services not rendered: The classic allegation, usually proved through patient interviews, appointment logs, and gaps between claim volume and staffing. Charges are commonly framed as grand theft under section 812.014, scaled by the amount alleged, or as federal healthcare fraud.
- Upcoding and unbundling: Billing a higher-paying code than the service supported, or splitting one procedure into several claims. These cases often turn on coding guidance that is genuinely ambiguous and on whether the provider relied on a billing company.
- Kickbacks and referral arrangements: Payments for patient referrals, lab orders, or prescriptions. Medical directorships, marketing contracts, and consulting fees can all be recast as illegal remuneration when the paper trail is thin.
- Home health and personal care agencies: Allegations that visits were not made, were shorter than billed, or were performed by unqualified workers. Agency owners and administrators are frequently charged alongside the aides.
- Pharmacy and durable medical equipment billing: Claims for prescriptions never dispensed, equipment never delivered, or supplies the patient did not need. Inventory records and wholesaler invoices are central evidence.
- Laboratory and diagnostic testing: Medically unnecessary testing, panels ordered by routine rather than need, and arrangements with referring physicians that prosecutors view as improper.
- Patient and recipient fraud: Individuals accused of misstating income, household size, or residency to obtain benefits, or of selling prescriptions or services. These cases can still be charged as felonies depending on the amount.
- Related federal counts: Wire fraud, false statements, conspiracy, aggravated identity theft, and money laundering are routinely added to billing cases, and forfeiture of accounts, vehicles, and real estate can follow.
What to Do If You Are Under Investigation for Medicaid Fraud
The first rule is to stop talking about the matter to investigators without counsel. Agents may present an interview as routine, a compliance check, or a chance to clear things up, and anything said can be used later, including an incomplete or inaccurate answer that becomes a false statement charge of its own. Be courteous, take the agent’s name and agency, and say that your lawyer will be in touch. If a subpoena, audit demand, or target letter has arrived, bring it to a lawyer before responding, because the manner in which records are produced can affect both your defenses and your exposure.
Preserve everything and change nothing. Do not delete files, edit patient charts, backfill documentation, or ask staff to “fix” records, since alterations can look like obstruction and are far more damaging than the original billing problem. Gather the documents that show how the practice actually operated: provider agreements, billing company contracts, coding guidance you relied on, credentialing records, and communications with consultants or accountants. If an outside biller or consultant handled claims, that relationship is often central to the question of intent.
Know where the case may be heard. Broward felony prosecutions are handled in the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, which covers Broward County only and whose main courthouse is in Fort Lauderdale. Federal charges are filed in the Southern District of Florida, and the federal courthouse for the Fort Lauderdale division sits in downtown Fort Lauderdale, with other divisions in Miami, West Palm Beach, Key West, and Fort Pierce. Because many providers have patients, locations, or billing activity in more than one county, the venue question is worth settling early. If arrest looks likely, arranging a voluntary surrender with counsel is generally far better than being taken into custody at a clinic or at home, and it can improve the footing for a bond discussion.
Finally, think about the business and the family. Frozen accounts, payment suspensions, exclusion from the program, and licensing board inquiries can arrive before any charge is filed. A defense plan should address those parallel consequences from the start, including whether property was seized from sources unrelated to the alleged billing.
How These Cases Are Built and Where They Can Be Challenged
Medicaid fraud prosecutions rest heavily on records and on witnesses who have their own interests. Former employees, billing staff, and patients may be cooperating after being offered leniency, and their accounts need to be tested against the documents. Statistical extrapolation, auditor assumptions about medical necessity, and the reading of ambiguous program rules are all open to challenge, often through expert review of the coding and the clinical records.
Intent is the center of most defenses. Evidence that a provider followed advice from a coder, accountant, or compliance consultant, that an error was corrected when discovered, or that billing practices matched common industry usage can separate a regulatory dispute from a crime. Search warrants and seizures of devices and charts raise their own questions about scope and particularity, and motions to suppress or to limit the use of seized materials can reshape the evidence available at trial.
Sentencing deserves attention long before a plea or verdict. In federal court, the alleged loss figure drives the guideline range, and there is no parole, so the sentence imposed is close to the time actually served. Contesting how loss is calculated, whether patients actually received legitimate services, and what role the individual actually played can matter as much as the verdict itself. In state court, the grade of the offense and the amount alleged similarly control the available penalties, along with fines that reach $10,000 for first- and second-degree felonies and $5,000 for third-degree felonies.
Questions About Medicaid Fraud Cases in Broward County
What is Medicaid fraud under Florida law?
It generally means knowingly submitting false or misleading claims, or otherwise deceiving the program to obtain payment or benefits that were not owed. Depending on the facts it may be charged as theft, as an insurance or healthcare fraud offense, or as a related crime such as false statements or conspiracy.
Who investigates Medicaid fraud in Broward County?
State investigators handle many cases, and federal agencies including the HHS Office of Inspector General and the FBI may be involved, particularly where Medicare or large dollar amounts are implicated. Which agency leads often determines whether a case is prosecuted in the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit or in federal court.
Can an honest billing mistake lead to criminal charges?
Prosecutors must show knowing, intentional deception, not just an error. In practice, however, a billing problem can still trigger a criminal investigation, and the quality of the records and the explanation given early on can influence whether the matter stays civil and administrative or becomes a prosecution.
What is the penalty for Medicaid fraud in Florida?
It depends on how the offense is charged and the amount involved. Where the conduct is prosecuted as grand theft, the grade rises with value: a third-degree felony from $750 up to $20,000, a second-degree felony from $20,000 up to $100,000, and a first-degree felony at $100,000 or more, carrying up to 5, 15, and 30 years respectively. Federal charges follow a separate sentencing scheme.
How long can the government wait to bring charges?
For most Florida felonies the window is three years, and four years for a first-degree felony, though a felony violation of section 817.234 has five years. Federal limitations periods differ, and ongoing conduct can complicate the calculation, so each count should be reviewed individually.
Should I speak with investigators if they say I am only a witness?
Not without counsel. Someone described as a witness can become a subject or target, and statements given in an informal interview can be used against you. A lawyer can find out your actual status and handle communications.
What if my billing company or an employee caused the problem?
That can be an important part of the defense on intent, but it does not end the inquiry, and investigators may still hold an owner or provider responsible for claims submitted under their number. Contracts, emails, and oversight practices become important evidence.
Can my medical license or Medicaid enrollment be affected?
Yes. Licensing boards and the program itself can take action separately from the criminal case, including suspension of payments or exclusion. Decisions made in the criminal case, such as a plea, can carry consequences in those proceedings, so they should be coordinated from the beginning.
Will my assets be seized during an investigation?
Possibly. Accounts can be frozen and property seized or made subject to forfeiture, particularly in federal cases involving money laundering counts. Early action can sometimes protect assets unconnected to the alleged conduct and limit disruption to a practice still operating.
How long does a Medicaid fraud case take in Broward County?
These cases usually take longer than ordinary criminal matters because discovery involves large volumes of billing data, patient records, and digital evidence. The investigation itself can run for months or years before charges, and a contested case can take a long time to reach trial.
Can I get a Spanish-speaking lawyer for a Medicaid fraud case?
Yes. Mr. Hassan is fluent in Spanish and speaks directly with clients and families without an interpreter, which helps when owners, staff, and relatives need to understand what is happening.
Medicaid Fraud Defense Across Broward County and South Florida
Our work for Broward County clients runs from Fort Lauderdale and Hollywood through Pembroke Pines, Miramar, Coral Springs, Plantation, Sunrise, Davie, Pompano Beach, Deerfield Beach, Weston, Lauderhill, Tamarac, Margate, and Coconut Creek. The firm also represents providers and individuals in neighboring Miami-Dade County, including Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens, as well as in Palm Beach County and Monroe County.
Because Medicaid and Medicare billing cases frequently cross county lines and involve federal agencies, the firm appears throughout the Southern District of Florida and in federal courts nationwide, and it handles matters connected to Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba. Whether a clinic is in Broward and its owner lives in Miami-Dade, or a case is brought in state court rather than federal court, the defense can be coordinated in one place.
Speak With a Broward County Medicaid Fraud Defense Attorney
If you have received a subpoena, an audit notice, a target letter, or a visit from investigators, the earliest decisions often have the greatest effect on the outcome. A Broward County Medicaid fraud defense attorney at the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. can review what you have received, explain what the government may be looking at, and help you decide how to respond. Call the firm at any hour to arrange a confidential consultation and begin building your defense.
