Broward County Obstruction of Justice Attorney
The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. defends people in Broward County who have been told, often with little warning, that the government now believes they interfered with an investigation or a court case. The firm handles federal and state criminal matters throughout Broward, Miami-Dade, Palm Beach, and Monroe Counties and the rest of the Southern District of Florida, and a Broward County obstruction of justice attorney is frequently called in after a client has already spoken to agents or deleted something they now wish they had kept.
Obstruction cases have a strange feature: they are often charged in addition to, or instead of, the underlying offense. A person who was a witness to someone else’s fraud can end up facing a count of their own because of what they said in an interview, a text message sent to a coworker, or a file that went missing from a laptop. In the Southern District of Florida, federal prosecutors working out of the Fort Lauderdale courthouse regularly add obstruction-type counts when they believe a subject lied to an agent, influenced a witness, or destroyed records after learning of an inquiry.
Whether the case is in federal court or a Broward state courtroom, the central fight is usually about what was in your head and what actually happened. Did you know a proceeding existed? Did you mean to interfere with it? Was the statement false, or just incomplete, mistaken, or misremembered? Those questions drive everything that follows.
Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for Obstruction Charges
Nayib Hassan, the firm’s attorney and founder, spent years as a Broward County Assistant State Attorney before moving to the defense side. He has more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system, handled thousands of cases as a prosecutor, and tried hundreds to verdict. That background matters in obstruction work because these charges depend on how a prosecutor reads a sequence of events. Mr. Hassan knows how charging decisions get made, what a prosecutor needs to see to feel comfortable at trial, and where the proof tends to be thinnest.
He is admitted to the Southern, Middle, and Northern District of Florida federal courts, the federal court for the District of Columbia, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, and he has defended clients in federal courts in Florida, the Southern District of New York, Texas, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, South Carolina, and California. He is recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, and serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. He is also an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University and has presented continuing legal education programs on federal court practice to other defense attorneys.
In multi-defendant federal cases, Mr. Hassan has obtained dismissals and has had a client receive one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. His cases have drawn coverage from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald. The firm deliberately keeps its caseload limited so the attorney handling your case is the one you talk to, and Mr. Hassan is fluent in Spanish, so Spanish-speaking clients and families can discuss the case directly with him. The firm is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and offers a confidential consultation.
Types of Obstruction Allegations We Defend in Broward County
- False Statements to Federal Agents: A casual conversation on a doorstep or a voluntary interview with the FBI, IRS Criminal Investigation, or Homeland Security Investigations can become its own federal charge if the government says an answer was knowingly false. These cases often turn on the agent’s notes rather than a recording, which makes the exact wording of the question and answer a central issue.
- Destruction or Alteration of Records: Deleted emails, wiped phones, shredded files, and altered invoices are charged as obstruction when prosecutors contend the person acted to keep material from an investigation or proceeding. The defense often focuses on whether there was any pending or foreseeable inquiry at the time and whether the deletion was routine.
- Witness Tampering and Intimidation: Contact with a witness, even a friendly one, can be characterized as an attempt to influence testimony. Text messages and recorded jail calls are the usual evidence, and context frequently changes the meaning of a message that looks bad in isolation.
- Obstructing a Grand Jury or Federal Proceeding: Lying to a grand jury, refusing to comply with a subpoena, or taking steps to hide documents that a subpoena covers can all lead to federal obstruction counts in addition to whatever the investigation was originally about.
- Obstruction Charged Alongside Fraud, Money Laundering, or Drug Conspiracy: In Broward and the Southern District of Florida, obstruction is often stacked onto white collar and narcotics indictments, and it can raise the guideline range at sentencing even when it is not charged as a separate count.
- State-Level Obstruction and Resisting Charges: In the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, which covers Broward County and only Broward County, people are also charged under Florida law for interfering with officers or hindering an investigation. Depending on how the charge is classified, these can be misdemeanors or felonies, and a felony case is heard in the circuit criminal division in Fort Lauderdale.
- Tampering With Evidence: Moving a gun, discarding a phone, or cleaning a scene can lead to evidence tampering allegations after a state investigation, even when the person did not commit the underlying offense.
What to Do If You Are Under Investigation or Have Been Charged
The first thing to do is stop talking about the case. That includes talking to agents, to coworkers, to relatives, and to anyone else who could later be asked what you said. Obstruction is one of the few areas of criminal law where the act of trying to explain yourself can create the offense. If agents contact you, be courteous, ask for a name and a way to reach them, and tell them that your lawyer will be in touch. You are not required to sit for an interview, and declining politely is not evidence of anything.
Second, preserve everything. If you have received a subpoena, a target letter, or even just a call from an investigator, do not delete, wipe, move, or reorganize any records, phones, or accounts, however innocent the reason. Many obstruction charges start with a person trying to tidy up. Tell your lawyer about anything that has already been lost or deleted so that it can be addressed before the government raises it.
Third, do not contact any person who may be a witness. Even a message that is meant to be friendly can be read later as pressure. If you need to communicate with a business partner or family member who may be involved, let your attorney decide how and whether that happens.
If you have been charged, the case will move differently depending on where it sits. Federal cases in this part of the state are heard in the Southern District of Florida, which holds court in Fort Lauderdale, Miami, West Palm Beach, Key West, and Fort Pierce. The Fort Lauderdale federal courthouse handles cases arising in Broward County. State felony cases from Broward are heard in the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit’s criminal division in Fort Lauderdale, and misdemeanors go to the Broward County Court’s criminal division. In federal court, expect an initial appearance, a detention hearing if the government asks for one, and then a stretch of discovery review and motion practice before any plea discussion or trial setting. Arranging a voluntary surrender, when possible, is far better than an arrest at your home or workplace.
Finally, the sooner a lawyer gets involved, the more room there is to act. During the investigation stage, counsel can sometimes correct an earlier statement, provide context to prosecutors, or influence which charges are brought. After an indictment, those options narrow quickly.
How Obstruction Cases Typically Unfold and What the Defense Looks At
Most obstruction cases begin with a separate investigation. An agent interviews someone, a subpoena goes out, or a search warrant is executed, and the government later compares what it was told with what its records show. Prosecutors then decide whether any discrepancy looks like deliberate interference rather than a faulty memory. Because the government has usually reviewed bank records, phone data, and communications for months, the person being questioned often does not realize how much is already known.
From the defense side, the analysis is about intent, materiality, and context. Intent is the heart of it: the government generally has to show you acted knowingly and with purpose, not that you made an honest mistake or said something imprecise. Materiality matters because a false statement usually has to be capable of affecting the investigation. Context matters because a deleted file, a late-night text, or an inconsistent answer can mean very different things depending on what the person knew at the time and what was being asked.
Defense work includes obtaining the agent’s notes and any recordings, testing whether the questions were clear, challenging the timing of the supposed obstructive act against the start of any proceeding, and looking at whether the government can actually tie the act to a particular investigation. Where the underlying case involves a charge that carries a first-degree felony classification in Florida, with a possible term of up to 30 years, or a third-degree felony with a maximum of 5 years, the classification of the obstruction offense and its connection to the main case can change the exposure and the negotiating posture considerably.
Sentencing is its own battleground in federal court. Obstruction can raise the guideline calculation, and a conviction on the main offense plus an obstruction count can compound each other. A thorough sentencing presentation challenges those enhancements and gives the judge reasons to impose a lower sentence. Because there is no parole in the federal system, the sentence imposed is close to the time actually served, which is why the firm takes these calculations seriously from the start.
Frequently Asked Questions About Obstruction of Justice in Broward County
What counts as obstruction of justice?
Obstruction covers a range of conduct aimed at interfering with an investigation or court proceeding. That includes lying to investigators, destroying or hiding records, influencing or threatening a witness, and ignoring a subpoena. The specific statute depends on whether the case is federal or state.
Can I be charged just for lying to an agent, even if I did nothing else wrong?
Yes. A false statement to a federal agent can be charged on its own, regardless of whether the underlying matter ever produces a case. That is why the safest course is to decline an interview until you have spoken with a lawyer.
Is it obstruction to delete texts or emails?
It can be, if the government can show you acted to keep the material from an investigation or proceeding. Routine deletion that happened before any inquiry is treated very differently from deletion after you learned agents were interested in you. The timing and your reason for deleting are usually the key facts.
What is the difference between state and federal obstruction charges in Broward?
Federal charges are brought by the United States Attorney’s Office and heard in the Southern District of Florida. State charges are filed by the State Attorney and heard in the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit or Broward County Court, depending on classification. Federal cases tend to involve longer investigations and guideline-driven sentencing.
What penalties can an obstruction charge carry?
It depends entirely on the statute and classification. Under Florida law, a first-degree felony can carry up to 30 years, a second-degree felony up to 15 years, and a third-degree felony up to 5 years, and a first-degree misdemeanor is punishable by up to a year in county jail. Federal penalties depend on the specific provision charged and on the sentencing guidelines.
How long after the event can someone be charged?
Florida sets time limits that vary with the classification of the offense. A first-degree felony generally must be commenced within 4 years, other felonies within 3 years, and a first-degree misdemeanor within 2 years, subject to the exceptions in the statute. Federal limitation periods are separate and depend on the charge.
Should I talk to a lawyer before responding to a subpoena?
Yes. How you respond to a subpoena, including what you produce and when, can itself create exposure if it is done carelessly. A lawyer can assess whether you are a witness, a subject, or a target, and can handle the response properly.
Can I be charged with obstruction if I was not guilty of the original crime?
Yes. Obstruction is a separate offense. A person who is not charged with, or is later cleared of, the underlying conduct can still face an obstruction count based on what the government says they did in response to the investigation.
Can an obstruction charge affect a professional license or a business?
It can. A conviction involving dishonesty or interference with a government inquiry can draw attention from licensing boards and regulators, and a federal case often brings parallel scrutiny of accounts and assets. These collateral issues should be raised with your lawyer early so they can be considered in any negotiation.
Will my record be eligible for sealing or expungement afterward?
That depends on how the case ends. Florida law generally bars sealing or expunction for a person adjudicated guilty of a felony, and a Certificate of Eligibility from FDLE is required before a court can act. Cases that end without a charge being filed, or with a dismissal or acquittal, may open the door to relief, though a court retains discretion to deny it.
Is it worth hiring a lawyer if I have only been contacted, not charged?
Often it is the best time to hire one. Before an indictment, counsel can communicate with prosecutors, prevent damaging statements, and sometimes influence whether charges are filed at all.
Serving Obstruction of Justice Clients Across Broward County and South Florida
The firm represents clients throughout Broward County, from Fort Lauderdale and Hollywood to Pembroke Pines, Miramar, Coral Springs, Pompano Beach, Davie, Plantation, Sunrise, Deerfield Beach, Weston, Lauderhill, Tamarac, Margate, Coconut Creek, and Hallandale Beach. Federal and state cases from these communities often end up in the Fort Lauderdale courthouses, and the firm appears in both.
The firm also serves clients in neighboring Miami-Dade County, including Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens, as well as Palm Beach County and Monroe County. Because federal practice is not limited by county lines, Mr. Hassan also represents clients charged in federal courts around the country, including matters with connections to Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba.
Talk to a Broward County Obstruction of Justice Lawyer Today
If agents have contacted you, a subpoena has arrived, or you have been charged, speak with a Broward County obstruction of justice lawyer before you say or do anything else. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is available around the clock, and a confidential consultation is the place to start. Call the firm today to talk through where you stand and what can still be done.
