Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Broward County Insurance Fraud Attorney
Miami Federal Criminal Defense Attorney / Broward County Insurance Fraud Attorney

Broward County Insurance Fraud Attorney

The best outcome in an insurance fraud investigation is the one where charges are never filed, and the second best is a case narrowed down to what the government can actually prove. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. defends individuals, business owners, and professionals accused of insurance fraud, including healthcare and Medicare billing cases, and serves clients throughout Broward County, the rest of South Florida, and federal courts nationwide. If you need a Broward County insurance fraud attorney, the decisions you make before anyone is arrested often matter more than anything that happens afterward.

Insurance fraud is rarely about one false statement. Prosecutors build these cases from claim files, recorded statements, medical records, billing data, bank deposits, and the testimony of adjusters, investigators, or cooperating witnesses. Whether a case is brought in state court in Fort Lauderdale or in federal court as mail fraud, wire fraud, or healthcare fraud depends on who the insurer is, how the claim was submitted, and how much money is involved. Choosing a defense strategy starts with knowing which system you are in.

What Separates a Claim Dispute From a Fraud Charge

Insurers deny, reduce, and contest claims every day, and most disputes never become criminal. A case crosses the line when the government believes someone knowingly made a false statement or submitted false information to obtain a payment or benefit. That word, knowingly, is where most defenses are built. An overstated repair estimate, a billing code entered by an employee, a medical provider’s documentation shortcut, or a claimant who misremembered the date of a loss can all look suspicious on paper without being intentional deceit.

Florida prosecutes insurance fraud under its own statutes, and the amount at issue often decides the charge through the same value tiers used in theft cases. Property valued at $750 or more but under $20,000 is a third-degree felony, $20,000 to under $100,000 is a second-degree felony, and $100,000 or more is a first-degree felony. A third-degree felony carries up to 5 years, a second-degree up to 15 years, and a first-degree up to 30 years, with fines of up to $5,000, $10,000, and $10,000 respectively. Because the dollar figure drives the exposure, how the government calculates it is one of the first things worth challenging.

The clock also matters. A felony violation of Florida’s insurance fraud provision, section 817.234, or the workers’ compensation fraud provision, section 440.105, must generally be prosecuted within 5 years of the violation, longer than the 3-year window that applies to most other third- and second-degree felonies. A claim from several years ago can still be charged, and a claim that falls outside the window may be a defense in itself.

Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for Insurance Fraud Defense

The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is a criminal defense firm led by attorney and founder Nayib Hassan, who spent years as a Broward County Assistant State Attorney before moving to the defense side. He has more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system, handled thousands of cases as a prosecutor, and tried hundreds to verdict. That background matters in fraud cases because he knows how charging decisions are made, what prosecutors need to survive a jury trial, and where a file that looks strong on the surface is thin underneath.

The firm serves clients in Broward County, Miami-Dade County, Palm Beach County, Monroe County, and across South Florida, and Mr. Hassan is admitted in the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida, the federal court for the District of Columbia, and the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals. He has defended clients in federal courts in Florida, the Southern District of New York, Texas, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, South Carolina, and California, and his cases have drawn coverage from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald. He is recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and teaches as an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University.

In multi-defendant cases, Mr. Hassan has obtained dismissed charges and, in another matter, one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. The firm limits its caseload so the attorney handling your case is the one you speak with, and it is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Mr. Hassan is fluent in Spanish and speaks with clients and families directly, and consultations are confidential.

Types of Insurance Fraud Cases We Defend in Broward County

  • Healthcare and Medicare Fraud: Physicians, pharmacy owners, clinic operators, home health agencies, equipment suppliers, laboratories, and billing staff face federal scrutiny over billing practices, referral arrangements, and kickback allegations involving Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurers.
  • Auto and Property Claim Fraud: Allegations that a vehicle loss, collision, storm damage, or theft was staged, inflated, or misreported to an insurer. Charges are graded by the value of the claim under Florida’s theft-based tiers.
  • Workers’ Compensation Fraud: Accusations that a worker exaggerated an injury or that an employer misreported payroll or classifications to reduce premiums, prosecuted under section 440.105 with a 5-year limitations period for felonies.
  • Provider Billing Fraud: Cases built on upcoding, billing for services not rendered, or unbundling procedures, where the real question is whether an error was intentional or a regulatory dispute.
  • Staged Accident and Claim-Ring Allegations: Conspiracy cases involving multiple participants, recorded statements, and cooperating witnesses, where one person’s account is used against everyone else.
  • Federal Mail and Wire Fraud: Claims submitted by mail, phone, or electronically can be charged federally in the Southern District of Florida, which includes Broward County and sits in Fort Lauderdale for court purposes.
  • False Statements and Material Misrepresentation: Applications, proofs of loss, and recorded interviews where an inaccurate answer is treated as a crime even when the underlying claim was real.
  • Asset Forfeiture Tied to Fraud Allegations: Bank accounts, vehicles, real estate, and business assets can be restrained or seized, leaving a family without resources while the case is pending.

What to Do If You Are Under Investigation for Insurance Fraud

Start by not explaining yourself. Special investigators from an insurer, agents from a state agency, or federal investigators may call, visit your home, or ask you to sit for a recorded statement. These conversations feel routine and cooperative, but anything you say can become evidence, and an inaccurate or incomplete answer can create a separate false-statement problem. Be polite, get the investigator’s name and contact information, and tell them your attorney will be in touch.

Next, preserve everything and change nothing. Claim files, estimates, invoices, emails, texts, photographs, and billing records should be kept exactly as they are. Deleting messages or altering records after you learn of an inquiry can turn a defensible case into an obstruction problem. If you operate a business or practice, the same applies to patient files, billing software data, and bank records.

The decision about whether to speak with prosecutors is a strategic one, and it should be made with a lawyer, not alone. Contacting the firm early can open options that disappear after charges are filed, such as presenting information to prosecutors, negotiating the scope of any charges, and arranging a voluntary surrender instead of an arrest. Do not move money or transfer assets in a panic; transactions made after an investigation begins can be portrayed as concealment.

If charges are filed, where the case goes depends on the charge. State felonies are heard in the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, which covers Broward County and only Broward County, and the circuit’s criminal division sits in Fort Lauderdale. Federal charges are filed in the Southern District of Florida, which holds court in Fort Lauderdale as well as Miami, West Palm Beach, Fort Pierce, and Key West. Expect an initial appearance, a bond decision, and then a long discovery phase in which the financial and claim records are examined line by line. Do not talk about the case with coworkers, family members who may be witnesses, or the insurer.

How These Cases Are Won or Narrowed

Intent is the center of most insurance fraud defenses. The government must show a deliberate falsehood, not an honest mistake, a misunderstanding of policy terms, or a sloppy employee. Defense work focuses on who actually prepared and submitted the claim, what the client knew at the time, and whether the paperwork shows a pattern or a one-time error.

The amount matters just as much. Because a claim’s value moves a case between a third-degree felony and a first-degree felony, and in federal court can push a sentence up quickly, challenging how the loss was calculated can change the exposure dramatically. We examine whether the government counted legitimate payments, double-counted amounts, or attributed a codefendant’s conduct to our client.

Evidence problems are common too. Recorded statements taken without a lawyer, documents obtained through overbroad warrants, and cooperating witnesses with a motive to shift blame all create openings for motions to suppress or dismiss. In conspiracy cases, the government often relies on one participant’s account against everyone else, which makes credibility and corroboration the real battleground. Where a case cannot be dismissed, a record built on these weaknesses supports negotiation for reduced charges or a lower sentence.

Frequently Asked Questions About Insurance Fraud Charges in Broward County

Is insurance fraud a felony in Florida?

It can be. The grade of the offense depends largely on the value involved. Amounts of $750 or more but under $20,000 are a third-degree felony, $20,000 to under $100,000 a second-degree felony, and $100,000 or more a first-degree felony. Lower amounts can be misdemeanors.

What is the maximum penalty for insurance fraud?

A first-degree felony carries up to 30 years, a second-degree felony up to 15 years, and a third-degree felony up to 5 years. Fines are separate, with ceilings of $10,000 for first- and second-degree felonies and $5,000 for third-degree felonies. Federal charges are governed by different statutes and the sentencing guidelines.

How long can prosecutors wait to file insurance fraud charges?

For a felony violation of the insurance fraud provision or the workers’ compensation fraud provision, the window is 5 years from the violation. Other third- and second-degree felonies generally allow 3 years, and first-degree felonies 4 years. Whether a time limit has run is something to review early.

Can insurance fraud be charged in federal court?

Yes. When a claim was submitted by mail, phone, or electronically, or involves Medicare, Medicaid, or a federally regulated program, prosecutors can bring mail fraud, wire fraud, or healthcare fraud charges in the Southern District of Florida. Federal cases are investigated for longer and tend to carry heavier sentencing exposure.

What should I do if an insurance investigator wants a recorded statement?

Do not give one before speaking with a lawyer. A recorded statement is evidence, and even a small inaccuracy can be used to argue intent. A lawyer can decide whether to respond, how, and under what conditions.

Can an honest billing mistake lead to criminal charges?

Investigators sometimes treat errors as fraud, but the government has to prove an intentional falsehood. Distinguishing a mistaken code, a staff error, or a regulatory disagreement from deliberate deception is the heart of many defenses, especially for medical providers.

Will I go to jail if I am convicted of insurance fraud?

Not automatically. Outcomes depend on the grade of the offense, the amount, prior record, and whether restitution is made. Early involvement by a lawyer can lead to reduced charges, alternative resolutions, or a sentence below the maximum, but no result is guaranteed.

Can a fraud conviction affect my professional license?

It can. Physicians, pharmacists, nurses, adjusters, contractors, and other licensed professionals may face separate licensing board action tied to a fraud accusation or conviction. Planning the criminal defense with that exposure in mind is important.

Can I get an insurance fraud record sealed or expunged?

It depends on how the case ends. A person adjudicated guilty of a felony cannot have the record expunged or sealed. If no charges were filed, or the case was dismissed or ended in acquittal, relief may be possible after a Certificate of Eligibility is obtained from FDLE, and a court still has discretion to deny the request.

How long does an insurance fraud case take in Broward County?

There is no fixed timeline. A case with a few claim files may move faster than one with thousands of billing records, and federal cases tend to take longer than state cases. Discovery in financial cases is often the longest phase.

Do you represent Spanish-speaking clients and families?

Yes. Mr. Hassan is fluent in Spanish and speaks directly with clients and relatives without an interpreter, which helps families make hard decisions with clear information.

Serving Broward County Insurance Fraud Clients and Neighboring Communities

Our defense work for Broward County clients covers Fort Lauderdale, Hollywood, Pembroke Pines, Miramar, Coral Springs, Pompano Beach, Davie, Plantation, Sunrise, Deerfield Beach, Weston, Lauderhill, Tamarac, Margate, Coconut Creek, and Oakland Park. Whether an investigation begins in a Hollywood medical clinic, a Plantation billing office, or a Pompano Beach body shop, the same decisions about statements, records, and timing apply.

The firm also represents clients in neighboring Miami-Dade County, including Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens, as well as Palm Beach County and Monroe County. Because Broward, Miami-Dade, Palm Beach, and Monroe all fall within the Southern District of Florida, the firm handles federal insurance and healthcare fraud cases across the region, and in federal courts across the country when a case is filed elsewhere.

Talk With a Broward County Insurance Fraud Attorney Today

If an insurer, state agency, or federal investigator has contacted you, or if a claim you submitted is under review, the safest next step is a confidential conversation before you respond to anyone. A Broward County insurance fraud attorney at the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. can explain what you are facing, what the government may be building, and which options are still open. Call the firm at any hour to arrange a consultation.

Book Your Consultation
* Required Field

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A., through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms