Miami-Dade County Insurance Fraud Attorney
The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. defends people across Miami-Dade County who are under investigation or charged with crimes involving insurance claims, from physicians and clinic owners to contractors, auto body operators, and individual policyholders. If you are looking for a Miami-Dade County insurance fraud attorney, the first thing to know is that these cases rarely begin with an arrest. They begin with a claims file, an adjuster’s referral, a records request, or a call from an investigator who describes the conversation as routine.
Insurance fraud in South Florida is prosecuted on two tracks. Staged accidents, inflated repair bills, and false property claims are typically charged under Florida law in the Eleventh Judicial Circuit. Schemes that touch Medicare, Medicaid, or other federal health programs are charged as federal healthcare fraud in the Southern District of Florida, often alongside wire fraud and conspiracy counts. Which court a case lands in changes the investigators, the prosecutors, the sentencing rules, and the strategy, so the earliest question in any engagement is who is actually building the case.
Most of these cases come down to a single issue: intent. A wrong number on a claim form, a billing code applied by an outside biller, or a repair estimate that grew after a supplement is not automatically a crime. Prosecutors have to show that someone knowingly made a false statement to get money. Our work is to find the gap between a documented mistake and a documented lie.
Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for Insurance Fraud Defense
Nayib Hassan, Attorney and Founder, is a former Broward County Assistant State Attorney with more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system. As a prosecutor he handled thousands of cases and tried hundreds to verdict, which means he knows how a fraud file is assembled, what investigators treat as strong evidence, and where their theories tend to strain. The firm defends individuals, business owners, executives, and professionals in Miami-Dade County, throughout South Florida, and in federal courts nationwide.
Mr. Hassan is admitted to the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida federal courts, the federal court for the District of Columbia, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. He is recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, and serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. He is also an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University and has presented continuing legal education programs on federal court practice to other defense attorneys. His cases have drawn coverage from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald.
Results in multi-defendant matters are relevant here, because insurance fraud cases often involve several people charged together. Mr. Hassan has represented defendants in multi-defendant drug cases, including matters where charges were dismissed and a case where his client received one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. The same skill applies when a clinic owner, a biller, and a provider are all pointing at one another.
The firm deliberately limits its caseload so that the attorney handling your case is the attorney you speak with. Mr. Hassan is fluent in Spanish and speaks directly with clients and relatives without an interpreter. The firm is reachable 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and consultations are confidential.
Types of Insurance Fraud Cases We Defend in Miami-Dade
- Staged and Exaggerated Auto Accident Claims: Accusations that a collision was arranged, that passengers were added who were not in the car, or that injuries were inflated. Florida’s insurance fraud statute, section 817.234, is the usual charging vehicle, and the amount of the claim often drives how seriously the case is treated.
- Medical Billing and Provider Fraud: Billing for services not rendered, upcoding, unbundling, or treating patients recruited through paid referrals. Clinic owners, physicians, and therapists in Miami-Dade face scrutiny from insurers’ special investigation units and from prosecutors.
- Medicare and Medicaid Fraud: Federal healthcare fraud involving pharmacies, home health agencies, durable medical equipment suppliers, and laboratories. These cases are investigated by agencies such as the HHS Office of Inspector General and prosecuted in the Southern District of Florida.
- Homeowner and Property Claim Fraud: Allegations of inflated hurricane or water damage claims, staged losses, or misrepresented repairs. Contractors and public adjusters who handle large volumes of storm claims can be drawn into these investigations alongside the homeowner.
- Application and Misrepresentation Fraud: False statements made when buying a policy, such as concealing a driver, a prior loss, or the true garaging address of a vehicle, and later charged as fraud when a claim is filed.
- Workers’ Compensation Fraud: Claims that an injury was invented, that someone worked while collecting benefits, or that an employer understated payroll to cut premiums. Section 440.105 violations carry their own charging rules.
- Related Theft and Wire Fraud Counts: Prosecutors frequently add grand theft, which is a first-degree felony at $100,000 or more, or federal wire fraud and conspiracy, so the real exposure can be far larger than the label “insurance fraud” suggests.
What to Do If You Are Contacted About an Insurance Fraud Investigation
Start by treating any contact from an investigator as significant, even if it is described as a routine follow-up. Insurers maintain special investigation units that build files before referring them to prosecutors, and a recorded statement given to a company investigator or an examination under oath can later be used in a criminal case. Do not sign anything, do not explain your billing or your claim from memory, and do not hand over documents without knowing what they will be used for. A false or incomplete answer to a federal agent can itself be charged as a false statement.
Preserve everything. Do not delete texts, emails, billing records, patient files, repair invoices, or photographs, and do not “clean up” paperwork. Altering records after you know of an inquiry can turn a defensible billing dispute into an obstruction problem. If devices or records have been seized, or a bank account has been frozen, call a lawyer the same day so that the warrant, the scope of the seizure, and the return of unrelated property can be examined.
Know which system you are in. State felony cases in Miami-Dade are heard by the Circuit Criminal Division of the Eleventh Judicial Circuit, which sits at the Richard E. Gerstein Justice Building. Federal cases are heard in the Southern District of Florida, and the Miami federal courthouses include the Wilkie D. Ferguson, Jr. United States Courthouse. Federal matters that stem from Broward, Palm Beach, or Monroe County can be heard in Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, or Key West. Which court has your case affects bond, discovery, and sentencing, and the firm appears in both state and federal courts.
Timing also matters. Under Florida law, a felony violation of section 817.234 must generally be charged within five years of the violation, longer than the three or four years that apply to many other felonies. That means a claim from several years ago can still be prosecuted. If you have been told you are a target, or if a former employee, patient, or business partner has started cooperating, early involvement of counsel can open options that fade once an indictment or information is filed, including presenting your side to prosecutors, negotiating the scope of charges, and arranging a voluntary surrender rather than an arrest.
How Insurance Fraud Cases Are Built and Where They Break Down
These prosecutions are document cases. Investigators compare claim forms, medical charts, repair estimates, bank records, and phone data, looking for patterns such as identical treatment across many patients, referral payments, or claims that do not match the physical evidence. Cooperating witnesses, often a former employee or a coconspirator seeking leniency, supply the story that ties the paper together.
A defense lawyer’s job is to test each link. We examine whether the statement alleged to be false was actually material, whether the person charged made it or merely signed what a biller or broker prepared, whether the loss figure is inflated by counting legitimate services, and whether a witness has a motive to shade testimony. Where evidence came from a search, a seizure, or a recorded statement, we look at whether it was lawfully obtained and whether a motion to suppress is warranted.
The value of the claim matters on both tracks. In state court, the alleged amount can determine the degree of a related theft count, and a first-degree felony carries up to 30 years, a second-degree felony up to 15, and a third-degree felony up to 5. In federal court, the alleged loss amount under the Sentencing Guidelines often has the largest effect on the recommended range, and there is no parole, so the sentence imposed is close to the time served. Challenging how loss is calculated is frequently where the most meaningful gains are made, whether at the charging stage, in plea negotiations, or at sentencing.
Questions About Insurance Fraud Charges in Miami-Dade
Is insurance fraud a state crime or a federal crime in Miami-Dade?
It can be either. Claims against private auto, property, and health insurers are usually prosecuted by the State Attorney under Florida law, while schemes involving Medicare, Medicaid, or other federal programs are prosecuted by the United States Attorney. Some cases involve both, and the same conduct can sometimes be charged in both systems.
What should I do if an insurance company investigator asks for a recorded statement?
Speak to a lawyer first. A recorded statement is evidence, and an investigator who asks for one may already be preparing a referral. A lawyer can decide whether to decline, limit the scope, or respond in writing.
How long can prosecutors wait to charge insurance fraud?
For a felony violation of Florida’s insurance fraud statute, section 817.234, prosecution must begin within five years of the violation. Related charges such as grand theft follow their own time limits, and federal charges follow federal limitations rules. A claim made years ago is not automatically safe.
Can I be charged if my biller or broker made the mistake?
Possibly, but the government still has to show you acted knowingly. Reliance on an accountant, biller, or broker, and the absence of any benefit to you from the error, can be central to the defense. How much you reviewed and signed is something prosecutors will examine closely.
What is the difference between a billing error and fraud?
An error is a mistake; fraud requires intent to deceive. Coding disputes, documentation gaps, and misreadings of payer rules are common in healthcare and are often resolved administratively. They become criminal when the evidence suggests a deliberate falsehood made to obtain payment.
Can insurance fraud be charged as grand theft?
Yes. Prosecutors often add grand theft based on the amount allegedly obtained. Under Florida law, theft of $100,000 or more is a first-degree felony, $20,000 to under $100,000 is a second-degree felony, and $750 to under $20,000 is a third-degree felony, so the claim amount can sharply raise the exposure.
Will I lose my professional license if I am charged?
A criminal case can trigger separate licensing proceedings for physicians, pharmacists, contractors, adjusters, and other licensed professionals, and a conviction can have serious consequences for a license. We coordinate the criminal defense so that statements and resolutions in one forum do not damage you in the other.
Can my bank accounts or property be seized before I am convicted?
Yes. Fraud and money laundering allegations often come with seizure or forfeiture of accounts, vehicles, and real estate, sometimes before any charge is filed. We challenge seizures that reach assets with no connection to the alleged conduct and work to recover property that should be returned.
Is it worth hiring a lawyer for a claim dispute that has not turned criminal?
Often, yes. When an insurer has referred a claim for investigation, or accuses you of misrepresentation, a lawyer can guide what you provide and say before a civil dispute becomes a criminal referral. Responses made without counsel are among the most common sources of later problems.
What if a coworker or partner is cooperating against me?
Cooperators receive benefits for their testimony, which gives them a reason to overstate what others did. We examine what the witness was promised, what they could corroborate with documents, and whether their account fits the records. Early contact with counsel matters because cooperation deals are often negotiated before others know a case exists.
Can a conviction for insurance fraud be sealed or expunged?
Generally not. Under Florida law, a person adjudicated guilty of a felony is not eligible for sealing or expunction, and a Certificate of Eligibility from FDLE is required before any court can act. This is why the outcome of the case itself, and avoiding an adjudication of guilt where possible, carries lasting weight.
Insurance Fraud Defense Across Miami-Dade County and South Florida
The firm represents clients throughout Miami-Dade County, including Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens. That coverage reaches the medical corridors where many clinics and practices operate, the commercial districts of Doral and Hialeah, and the residential neighborhoods where homeowner and auto claims originate.
Insurance fraud investigations do not stop at county lines, so the firm also represents clients in neighboring Broward County, Palm Beach County, and Monroe County, and in the federal courts of the Southern District of Florida. Mr. Hassan has defended clients in federal courts across the country, including the Southern District of New York, Texas, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, South Carolina, and California, and handles matters connected to Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba. Hablamos español, and clients and families can discuss their case directly in Spanish.
Talk to a Miami-Dade Insurance Fraud Defense Attorney Today
If an insurer, an agent, or a prosecutor has contacted you about a claim, the choices you make now, including what you say, what you sign, and what you turn over, can shape everything that follows. A Miami-Dade insurance fraud defense attorney at the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. can step in before charges are filed, deal with investigators on your behalf, and build a defense around the actual evidence. Call the firm at any hour to arrange a confidential consultation.
