Miami Durable Medical Equipment Fraud Attorney
The best outcome in a durable medical equipment investigation is one that never reaches an indictment, and the second best is a case where the government’s theory of intent and loss falls apart under scrutiny. The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. defends supplier owners, billing staff, marketers, and physicians accused of DME fraud, and works to get there. As a Miami durable medical equipment fraud attorney practice within a federal criminal defense firm, we represent clients in Miami, Miami-Dade County, and across South Florida, from the first agent contact through trial, sentencing, and appeal.
DME cases are paper cases. Prosecutors build them from claims data, prescriptions, delivery records, physician orders, and bank accounts, then ask a jury to infer that a supplier knew the billing was false. The inference is where these cases are won and lost. A wheelchair, brace, or orthotic that was ordered, delivered, and billed under a confusing coverage rule is very different from a scheme built on forged orders and paid-for patient leads, yet both can look the same in an auditor’s spreadsheet.
Miami-Dade has been one of the country’s most closely watched regions for Medicare billing enforcement, and DME suppliers sit squarely in that focus. If you have received a target letter, a grand jury subpoena, a payment suspension notice, or a visit from agents, what you say and produce in the next few days matters enormously.
How Federal Prosecutors Build a DME Fraud Case
Most DME prosecutions begin quietly. Claims analytics flag a supplier whose billing is out of line with peers, a beneficiary reports a product they never received, or a cooperating witness, often a former employee or an indicted marketer, points agents toward the owner. The HHS Office of Inspector General and the FBI typically lead, sometimes with prosecutors from the Southern District of Florida’s health care fraud units and a Medicare contractor supplying the audit data. Months of record review can pass before the target learns anything.
The charges usually rest on a handful of statutes: health care fraud, conspiracy, false statements relating to health care matters, payments or receipt of kickbacks under the Anti-Kickback Statute, wire fraud, and money laundering when proceeds moved through other accounts or entities. Because each billed claim can be charged as its own count and because the alleged loss drives the sentencing range under the United States Sentencing Guidelines, the government’s loss number is often the single most contested figure in the case.
Why Choose the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. for DME Fraud Defense
The Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. is a federal criminal defense firm serving Miami, Miami-Dade County, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe Counties, and clients in federal courts nationwide. Founder Nayib Hassan is a former Broward County Assistant State Attorney with more than 20 years inside the criminal justice system. As a prosecutor he handled thousands of cases and tried hundreds to verdict, which means he knows how charging decisions get made and how prosecutors weigh trial risk when a case has weaknesses.
Mr. Hassan is admitted to the federal courts in the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida, the District of Columbia, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. He has defended clients in federal courts in Florida, the Southern District of New York, Texas, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, South Carolina, and California. He is recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, holds a 10.0 Avvo rating, serves on the Miami board of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and teaches as an adjunct professor at St. Thomas University. He has also presented continuing legal education programs on federal court practice to other defense attorneys.
In multi-defendant federal cases, which describes most DME conspiracies, Mr. Hassan has obtained dismissals of charges and, in other matters, one of the lowest sentences among all codefendants. His cases have drawn coverage from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, CNN, and the Miami Herald. The firm limits its caseload so the attorney handling your case is the attorney you speak with, and Mr. Hassan is fluent in Spanish, so Spanish-speaking owners and families can discuss the case directly with their lawyer. The firm is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and offers confidential consultations.
Common DME Fraud Allegations and Related Charges
- Billing for Equipment Never Delivered: The government alleges claims were submitted for wheelchairs, braces, or monitors that beneficiaries never received. Delivery logs, signed receipts, and warehouse records are often the deciding evidence.
- Upcoding and Medically Unnecessary Items: Billing a higher-priced item than the one supplied, or supplying items a patient did not need. These cases frequently turn on whether a physician’s order supported the claim and whether the supplier knew otherwise.
- Kickbacks and Paid Patient Referrals: Payments to marketers, recruiters, clinics, or physicians in exchange for orders or beneficiary leads can be charged under the federal Anti-Kickback Statute, often alongside conspiracy.
- Forged or Purchased Physician Orders: Prosecutors allege prescriptions were signed without a genuine patient relationship or bought in bulk. Owners who relied on third-party lead generators are often exposed here even without personal involvement.
- Beneficiary Identity Misuse: Use of patient numbers obtained from brokers or data sellers can add aggravated identity theft counts, which carry a consecutive prison term when proven.
- Money Laundering Through Shell Entities: Moving Medicare proceeds through related companies, real estate, or overseas accounts can add money laundering counts under 18 U.S.C. 1956 and 1957 and widen forfeiture.
- Medicaid and Private Insurer Billing: Medicaid and commercial plans can be pursued under federal health care fraud or wire fraud statutes, and Florida theft statutes may apply in state cases, with grand theft graded by the value taken.
- Enrollment and Accreditation Misstatements: False statements on supplier enrollment forms, about ownership, location, or licensure, can be charged as false statements even without a billing loss.
What to Do When Agents Contact You or Your Supplier Company
If agents come to your business or home, be courteous but do not answer substantive questions and do not hand over records voluntarily. A statement that is incomplete or inaccurate can become its own false statement charge, and an interview you believed was routine can be the evidence used to charge you. Ask for each agent’s name and agency, say you will have your attorney contact them, and call a federal defense lawyer right away. If agents arrive with a search warrant, do not obstruct, but do not explain, and do not instruct employees to discard or alter anything; obstruction is a far easier charge to prove than fraud.
A target letter or grand jury subpoena changes the picture. These come from the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Florida, and a response deadline may be short. A lawyer can often negotiate scope, preserve documents correctly, and decide whether an attorney proffer or presentation to prosecutors makes sense. Employees may be contacted at home, so owners should consider telling staff they are free to speak with counsel before speaking with agents. Preserve everything: billing software exports, delivery confirmations, physician order files, marketer contracts, and text messages. Do not wipe phones or delete accounts.
If charges are filed, Miami federal cases are heard at the federal courthouses in downtown Miami, including the Wilkie D. Ferguson, Jr. United States Courthouse. Cases arising in Broward, Palm Beach, or Monroe Counties may be heard in Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, or Key West. Early priorities include a bond argument at the initial appearance, a voluntary surrender when an arrest can be avoided, and an early look at whether business accounts were frozen. Related Florida state allegations are heard in the Eleventh Judicial Circuit, which serves Miami-Dade County.
Defense Issues That Decide DME Fraud Cases
Intent is the center of nearly every DME case. Medicare coverage rules are dense, documentation requirements change by product category, and honest suppliers regularly get claims wrong. The government must show the supplier knowingly submitted false claims, not that a claim was denied, clawed back, or sloppily documented. Evidence that an owner relied on a billing company, consultant, or compliance advisor, or that audits in the past ended in repayment rather than referral, can undercut an inference of fraud.
Loss amount is the second battleground. The government often treats every dollar billed by a flagged supplier as fraudulent, but equipment that was medically necessary, ordered by a real physician, and delivered to a real patient is legitimate revenue even if paperwork was flawed. Separating those claims can reduce the guideline range dramatically, and with no parole in the federal system the sentence imposed is close to the time served. Forfeiture of accounts, vehicles, and real estate is also pursued in these cases, and we contest it alongside the criminal charges, including property with no connection to the alleged scheme.
Owners who are cooperating witnesses against others, or who are asked to, face a separate set of decisions. Whether to cooperate, when, and on what terms should be evaluated by someone who has sat on both sides of that negotiation and who understands what a cooperation agreement actually requires and risks.
Questions About Durable Medical Equipment Fraud Cases
What counts as durable medical equipment fraud?
It is the knowing submission of false or misleading claims to Medicare, Medicaid, or private insurers for equipment such as wheelchairs, braces, oxygen concentrators, glucose monitors, and similar items. It also includes related conduct such as paying kickbacks for orders or falsifying supplier enrollment information.
Can I be prosecuted for an honest billing mistake?
Federal health care fraud requires proof that the defendant acted knowingly and willfully. Errors, misread coverage rules, and poor documentation are generally civil or administrative matters, but the government may still argue the pattern shows intent. The defense is built on showing what you knew and why.
What should I do if I get a target letter?
Do not ignore it and do not call the agents yourself. A target letter means prosecutors believe they have substantial evidence tying you to a crime, and it is one of the best moments for a lawyer to step in because there may still be room to influence charging decisions.
Will Medicare stop paying my company while I am under investigation?
Payments can be suspended when there is credible evidence of fraud, and enrollment can be revoked. These administrative actions run alongside the criminal case and carry their own deadlines, so they should be addressed with counsel promptly.
Can employees, billers, or marketers be charged even if they do not own the company?
Yes. Anyone who knowingly participates in a scheme can be charged as a conspirator, including billers, office managers, recruiters, and physicians who sign orders. Their roles and knowledge are often very different from the owner’s, which affects both defense strategy and exposure.
How is the loss amount calculated in a DME case?
The government typically starts with the total amount billed or paid on claims it considers fraudulent. Defense work often focuses on carving out claims for legitimate, delivered, and medically supported equipment, because a lower loss figure reduces the recommended sentence under the Guidelines.
Is a kickback to a marketer always a crime?
Payments to induce referrals of federally reimbursed business can violate the Anti-Kickback Statute, but not every marketing or lead arrangement does, and the law has recognized exceptions and safe harbors. Whether a particular arrangement qualifies is a fact-specific question that should be reviewed before agents ask about it.
What happens to my bank accounts and property?
Prosecutors can freeze or seize accounts and seek forfeiture of money, vehicles, and real estate they say are tied to the offense. Funds from unrelated sources can be protected, and seizures can be challenged, so contact a lawyer as soon as an account is frozen.
Do state charges ever apply to DME billing?
Yes. Florida prosecutors can charge theft-based offenses, with grand theft graded by value: a third-degree felony from $750 up to $20,000, a second-degree felony from $20,000 up to $100,000, and a first-degree felony at $100,000 or more. Insurance fraud felonies under s. 817.234 carry a five-year limitations period.
Does a conviction affect a physician’s or pharmacist’s license?
Professional licensing boards and Medicare exclusion authorities can act on a fraud conviction or even on the underlying allegations, independent of the criminal outcome. Licensed clients should have the criminal strategy and the licensing exposure considered together.
Is it worth hiring a lawyer if I have only been asked for records?
A records request can be the first sign of an investigation, and what you produce and say in response can shape whether charges are ever filed. Early representation often preserves options that disappear once an indictment is returned.
How long does a federal DME fraud case take?
Investigations can run for years before charges, and a charged case commonly takes many months to over a year to reach trial or plea, depending on the volume of discovery and the number of defendants. Complex multi-defendant cases tend to take longer.
Serving Miami and South Florida DME Fraud Defendants
The firm represents DME suppliers, owners, and staff throughout Miami and Miami-Dade County, including Hialeah, Doral, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Kendall, Aventura, North Miami, Homestead, and Miami Gardens. We also serve clients in Broward County, Palm Beach County, and Monroe County, where federal cases may be heard in the Southern District of Florida’s Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, and Key West courthouses. Because federal practice is not limited by county lines, the firm takes cases in federal courts across the country and in matters involving Colombia, Mexico, the Bahamas, Ecuador, and Cuba. We also defend related state-level cases throughout Florida.
Speak With a Miami DME Fraud Defense Attorney
If agents have contacted you, your accounts have been frozen, or a subpoena or target letter has arrived, reach out to a Miami DME fraud defense attorney at the Law Office of Nayib Hassan, P.A. before you respond to anyone. Call to arrange a confidential consultation at any hour. The decisions made in the first days of a federal health care investigation often shape what options remain.
